Think about it. If they do a Halo 2 Anniversary, they couldn’t just stop there. The Xbox 360’s servers aren’t going to stay up forever. If they did do a H2A, they’d be faced with a problem. They would HAVE to do a Halo 3 Anniversary after that, wouldn’t they? And then if they’ve already done those three over the next few years, they can’t just stop there, can they? Come 2019, they might even do an ODST Anniversary, probably do a Reach one, and then the year after that, heaven forbid, release a Combat Evolved Anniversary Anniversary.
(Full disclosure for the paragraphs ahead: I’m among the many Halo 4 criticizers. Keep that in mind.)
Trust me, if they expanded it to Halo 2 Anniversary instead of just the classic first one, there is no WAY they would be able to stop. We sure as heck wouldn’t let them.
If they started doing it, they would probably get massive criticism from all across the gaming industry for continually recycling their 10-year-old games, giving it a fresh coat of paint & calling it “new,” and then putting it back on the market to milk us for more money, based off of something they didn’t actually create. Honestly, if they kept doing that, those criticisms would be mostly accurate.
If you’ll remember, Frankie said that they only made CEA because it “made sense.” If they did end up making a H2A, they’d be kind of backing themselves into a corner.
Trust me, I would LOVE to have a Halo 2 Anniversary. I joined the fight with Halo 3 in 2008, but one day after beating 2’s campaign, I was checking out the muliplayer maps, and I found myself fantasizing of all the good times I wish I could have had, had I joined in with Halo 2.
It also happens to have my favorite campaign (Well, other than 4’s, now), not to mention the remastered soundtrack for it would probably be AMAZING, as I’m especially curious as to what they would do with songs like “Peril,” the main theme song, or the Breaking Benjamin song that plays during the huge Arbiter Colosseum battle. It would also be sweet seeing what the Arbiter looks like with 343’s new art style, and having some new terminals, and being able to turn the skulls on without having to collect them every time you got back into the game. And it would be awesome if they added music to the boss fights and gave them more flair, most notably the rock theme for the final battle against Tartarus, and… Crap, I’m fantasizing again.
So, anyway, it would be GREAT if they did it, but they shouldn’t, honestly.
Trust me, I want them to do it. But at the same time, I hope they don’t.