Why do people claim that Noble survived?

It’s everyone on Noble. Not just Six, Jorge and Carter, which is ridiculous, but I’ve seen some say that even Emile and Kat survived. Why?

To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.

> 2535442193107125;2:
> To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.

This is correct

I’m just saying we don’t see Six die. Everyone else we assume are dead we saw get killed some how but if you watch the footage from Noble Six’s helmet you never seem him get cut. He seems to dodge every single sword that is swung at him until the last one cuts off mid swipe. We neither see him get stabbed or see his body and the elite thrusting when it cuts off is only using an energy knife not an energy sword. I am just saying I think they left it open for your own interpretation. They show everyone else actually receiving fatal blows but not him. I don’t think we will ever see him again but it is nice to think he survived and escaped somehow especially since all we know about six prior to Reach is that he specialized in being a lone wolf. Just worth a thought haha (also I am basing ALL of this off the game as I have played it countless times but I have never read the books)

> 2533274813317074;3:
> > 2535442193107125;2:
> > To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.
>
> This is correct

Hey is there a definitive source that I can cite on Jorge being dead I’m in another thread and I’ve got multiple people saying there is no such source

> 2533274862926994;5:
> Hey is there a definitive source that I can cite on Jorge being dead I’m in another thread and I’ve got multiple people saying there is no such source

https://www.halowaypoint.com/en-us/universe/characters/jorge-052.

BORN:
MARCH 5, 2511

DIED:
AUGUST 14, 2552

> 2533274862926994;5:
> > 2533274813317074;3:
> > > 2535442193107125;2:
> > > To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.
> >
> > This is correct
>
> Hey is there a definitive source that I can cite on Jorge being dead I’m in another thread and I’ve got multiple people saying there is no such source

Waypoint, Halopedia, Halo Nation, on every single official site, he’s listed as confirmed KIA on August 14th, 2552.

> 2535468977530447;7:
> > 2533274862926994;5:
> > > 2533274813317074;3:
> > > > 2535442193107125;2:
> > > > To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.
> > >
> > > This is correct
> >
> > Hey is there a definitive source that I can cite on Jorge being dead I’m in another thread and I’ve got multiple people saying there is no such source
>
> Waypoint, Halopedia, Halo Nation, on every single official site, he’s listed as confirmed KIA on August 14th, 2552.

I knew about Halopedia and Halo nation but was looking for something a bit more concrete. kinda embarrassing that I didn’t think of waypoint… My first instinct was to look at the data that came in the black box with the game but I realized that would spoil the game so yeah then i stumbled in here.
Woop Woop Woop Woop skuttles away

> 2535442199308642;4:
> I’m just saying we don’t see Six die. Everyone else we assume are dead we saw get killed some how but if you watch the footage from Noble Six’s helmet you never seem him get cut. He seems to dodge every single sword that is swung at him until the last one cuts off mid swipe. We neither see him get stabbed or see his body and the elite thrusting when it cuts off is only using an energy knife not an energy sword. I am just saying I think they left it open for your own interpretation. They show everyone else actually receiving fatal blows but not him. I don’t think we will ever see him again but it is nice to think he survived and escaped somehow especially since all we know about six prior to Reach is that he specialized in being a lone wolf. Just worth a thought haha (also I am basing ALL of this off the game as I have played it countless times but I have never read the books)

… No. I’ll let the other Waypointers talk here.

> 2533274862926994;8:
> > 2535468977530447;7:
> > > 2533274862926994;5:
> > > > 2533274813317074;3:
> > > > > 2535442193107125;2:
> > > > > To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.
> > > >
> > > > This is correct
> > >
> > > Hey is there a definitive source that I can cite on Jorge being dead I’m in another thread and I’ve got multiple people saying there is no such source
> >
> > Waypoint, Halopedia, Halo Nation, on every single official site, he’s listed as confirmed KIA on August 14th, 2552.
>
> I knew about Halopedia and Halo nation but was looking for something a bit more concrete. kinda embarrassing that I didn’t think of waypoint… My first instinct was to look at the data that came in the black box with the game but I realized that would spoil the game so yeah then i stumbled in here.
> Woop Woop Woop Woop skuttles away

To be fair though, both are pretty concrete. Waypoint is the best source of course.

> 2533274824050480;9:
> > 2535442199308642;4:
> > I’m just saying we don’t see Six die. Everyone else we assume are dead we saw get killed some how but if you watch the footage from Noble Six’s helmet you never seem him get cut. He seems to dodge every single sword that is swung at him until the last one cuts off mid swipe. We neither see him get stabbed or see his body and the elite thrusting when it cuts off is only using an energy knife not an energy sword. I am just saying I think they left it open for your own interpretation. They show everyone else actually receiving fatal blows but not him. I don’t think we will ever see him again but it is nice to think he survived and escaped somehow especially since all we know about six prior to Reach is that he specialized in being a lone wolf. Just worth a thought haha (also I am basing ALL of this off the game as I have played it countless times but I have never read the books)
>
> … No. I’ll let the other Waypointers talk here.
>
>
> > 2533274862926994;8:
> > > 2535468977530447;7:
> > > > 2533274862926994;5:
> > > > > 2533274813317074;3:
> > > > > > 2535442193107125;2:
> > > > > > To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.
> > > > >
> > > > > This is correct
> > > >
> > > > Hey is there a definitive source that I can cite on Jorge being dead I’m in another thread and I’ve got multiple people saying there is no such source
>
> To be fair though, both are pretty concrete. Waypoint is the best source of course.

I know but I wanted a source that couldn’t be argued with. I mean we saw it happen in game and that is pretty concrete too.

> 2535468977530447;1:
> It’s everyone on Noble. Not just Six, Jorge and Carter, which is ridiculous, but I’ve seen some say that even Emile and Kat survived. Why?

Ok I have to know who is saying Kat survived and how does that argument go… She is alive, now she has a prosthetic arm and a prosthetic brain.

> 2533274862926994;11:
> > 2535468977530447;1:
> > It’s everyone on Noble. Not just Six, Jorge and Carter, which is ridiculous, but I’ve seen some say that even Emile and Kat survived. Why?
>
> Ok I have to know who is saying Kat survived and how does that argument go… She is alive, now she has a prosthetic arm and a prosthetic brain.

I don’t remember their name, of course, but they were on Hidden Xperia’s ‘Did Noble Six Survive Halo Reach?’ video. Brace yourself for this, I lost quite a few brain cells. They said that since no one in game said she died, she could’ve survived but just been severely injured.

> 2533274862926994;10:
> > 2533274824050480;9:
> > > 2535442199308642;4:
> > > I’m just saying we don’t see Six die. Everyone else we assume are dead we saw get killed some how but if you watch the footage from Noble Six’s helmet you never seem him get cut. He seems to dodge every single sword that is swung at him until the last one cuts off mid swipe. We neither see him get stabbed or see his body and the elite thrusting when it cuts off is only using an energy knife not an energy sword. I am just saying I think they left it open for your own interpretation. They show everyone else actually receiving fatal blows but not him. I don’t think we will ever see him again but it is nice to think he survived and escaped somehow especially since all we know about six prior to Reach is that he specialized in being a lone wolf. Just worth a thought haha (also I am basing ALL of this off the game as I have played it countless times but I have never read the books)
> >
> > … No. I’ll let the other Waypointers talk here.
> >
> >
> > > 2533274862926994;8:
> > > > 2535468977530447;7:
> > > > > 2533274862926994;5:
> > > > > > 2533274813317074;3:
> > > > > > > 2535442193107125;2:
> > > > > > > To my knowledge, only Jun survived as he also went on to train some of the next groups of spartans. Everyone else on Noble team is confirmed dead.
> > > > > >
> > > > > > This is correct
> > > > >
> > > > > Hey is there a definitive source that I can cite on Jorge being dead I’m in another thread and I’ve got multiple people saying there is no such source
> >
> > To be fair though, both are pretty concrete. Waypoint is the best source of course.
>
> I know but I wanted a source that couldn’t be argued with. I mean we saw it happen in game and that is pretty concrete too.

I don’t agree with half of the things people said in that thread about him going off to do crazy stuff, and yes if he survived SOMEHOW then he would report back to ONI. I just think details like us not seeing him get stabbed and them not finding a body or blood near the helmet is all interesting. Like in the real world those could be just coincidence but in this format they purposefully wrote that. They decided that was how they wanted it to be seen. So you as an individual can decided what become of the character that was most you. Six was what ever you wanted him/her to be and in the end you also decide the details of their death. Is it likely? no not at all. Will he make an appearance ever again? Certainly not no way. Just worth thinking about.