Why Did I Get Banned - The Official Thread

> The whole system is flawed. I really hope since 343 has taken over it will progressively get better. I noticed as soon as they did nothing changed in the connection and I get temporarily banned from matchmaking when I accidentally betray someone or my internet cuts out. (And don’t feed me the BS about that won’t ban someone if they disconnect) Hopefully When I write my review for Halo 4 I can tell our fans that you were able to improve on the matchmaking, but if this is just the same as halo reach then we will know that 343 cannot carry the mantle that Bungie left behind.

It’s not flawed. Lagging out from a game is still a quit no matter what, same when you get booted.

I let my four year old play, so i am punished with a ban. she gets alot of negitives due to suicides, screw this i payed and pay good money. for Xbox halo and the whole anyone wanna buy, playstation is calling me. angry reader, player

I wish to appell Ban on my halo Reach I Beleve My Accout was Hacked, As A gamer thratend to hack my account while we were playing Grifball. i have alerted X box live to this.

> > The whole system is flawed. I really hope since 343 has taken over it will progressively get better. I noticed as soon as they did nothing changed in the connection and I get temporarily banned from matchmaking when I accidentally betray someone or my internet cuts out. (And don’t feed me the BS about that won’t ban someone if they disconnect) Hopefully When I write my review for Halo 4 I can tell our fans that you were able to improve on the matchmaking, but if this is just the same as halo reach then we will know that 343 cannot carry the mantle that Bungie left behind.
>
> It’s not flawed. Lagging out from a game is still a quit no matter what, same when you get booted.

I have to agree with SHEPZERO; in my opinion, it does have flaws, as shown by many of the previous posts… and in my example with the Firefight, you shouldn’t be banned for trying to do something they offer. Now that I look at it, playing it over and over could be seen as credit farming since you get credits easily in it, which is what I’m assuming caused the ban. However, during challenges like I said, there should have been something to recognize the player is attempting to get them done, and ignore how many credits they get along the way. But this is my opinion; anyone else’s view could be different. This is mine.

As for 343 making the system better, I don’t think that will happen soon, if it all. I’m sure they have a lot of work to do on the Halo 4 server at the time being. If they come around to fixing it, it will not be any time soon.

Hi
I’m not sure if i am banned or what, but i am not receiving any credits for completing games for some reason. I have reached the daily credit limit a number of times this week, due to being sick and having nothing to do but play halo. I reached it today, and when the new daily challenges came out, i went to play some more, thinking the credit limit would be lifted and i could continue earning my credits. But to my surprise, i am still not earning credits.

Is the credit limit supposed to be reset at the same time as the daily challenges? This was my understanding, and i am afraid that i may have been banned. I haven’t received any messages at all. I am really confused…

Any help/info would be greatly appreciated.

Hi,

My gamertag is PlayinForK33ps and I was playing with a guest the other day and was credit banned.
Though my guest was a first time player and averaged 0-2 kills per game, I was leading the scoreboard more often than not.
My guest was active, however badly she played, and I was contributing to the team : Why was I banned?
I have quite a few videos in the theater proving we weren’t idle.

I recently got banned because I had my daughter play swat with me and she never gets any kills and I get banned? What the eff. So basically it means if you suck don’t play??? This needs to get fixed I don’t think it’s ok. I don’t even get a message when the ban will left either so what can I do? I hate that I know have to tell my daughter she can’t play cuz she basically sucks or I get banned so stupid.!!!

I received an in-game message saying i was banned from earning credits while playing firefight. I have no clue why. I’ve only had the 10 min ban in the past and never a 24 hour ever, but it has been 3-4 days, and i just want to know why and how long i will be banned

> Hi,
>
> My gamertag is PlayinForK33ps and I was playing with a guest the other day and was credit banned.
> Though my guest was a first time player and averaged 0-2 kills per game, I was leading the scoreboard more often than not.
> My guest was active, however badly she played, and I was contributing to the team : Why was I banned?
> I have quite a few videos in the theater proving we weren’t idle.

The ban hammer goes solely off kills in terms of bans for AFKing.

There is no appeal process.

> I recently got banned because I had my daughter play swat with me and she never gets any kills and I get banned? What the eff. So basically it means if you suck don’t play??? This needs to get fixed I don’t think it’s ok. I don’t even get a message when the ban will left either so what can I do? I hate that I know have to tell my daughter she can’t play cuz she basically sucks or I get banned so stupid.!!!

Pretty much :confused:

Just stick to Custom Games, Forge, Firefight & Campaign until she can get at least one kill a game to avoid bans.

> I received an in-game message saying i was banned from earning credits while playing firefight. I have no clue why. I’ve only had the 10 min ban in the past and never a 24 hour ever, but it has been 3-4 days, and i just want to know why and how long i will be banned

You were banned due to your AFKing activity in this game: Team Snipers on Hemorrhage

If your ban doesn’t end after one week, then you have a two week ban.

i was playing firefight matchmaking the other day when a message popped up on my screen in the middle of my game saying i was being banned from earning credits. I dont know why i have been banned, i have received 10 min bans in the past long ago… but never a 24 hour ban, i would just like to know why i am being banned and for how long, so I can prevent this from happening in the future thank you

So I am Banned for the first time ever. Was it because i stopped playing to help my niece with her chore and was idle for one game? If so I think it is pretty stupid :confused:

This is a lil strict for someone who hasn’t played reach in year and just started back playing again to get in the groove for halo 4. way to go 343 im super excited about this ban :smiley:

I feel like ive been grounded lol Its lame i pay money to be able to play and lvl up!! this ban hammer as ive seen it being called needs to be put to death!!

I was playing Halo this past weekend (gamertag McWelder) with my 10 year old daughter (Gamertag DeadlyK1tt3n) - she has just started playing Halo, NO KILLS which then resulted in a credit ban to my game console. Because the system views this as AFK when a gamer gets no kills. Seriously. I pay all this money for xbox live account - games - dlc and you say you can’t remove the bans or give any definite answer as too how long it will last…or that you can’t remove the bans. Which I find hard to believe. Seriously pissed off customer…Gee and I preordered and paid already for my Halo 4 Limited Edition, Halo 4 Xbox and Halo 4 Tritons…seriously this is how it going to go?

same here all the above ^

Hey all, I’m not arguing my first ban ever, but is there anyway to tell what kind of ban one has in regards to the time limit?

Hey This is my first time getting a temp. ban. It says the following: This account has been temp. banned from earning credits. Then says Accounts on this Xbox 360 console has been banned from earning credits.

I am just curious what caused my temp. ban? I played Anniversary Firefight most of the afternoon sometimes getting over 4000 score then jetpacking up and AFKing. I played a few matchmaking games with a AFK guest because I get tired of getting paired up with people who always get in my way or just run out and die all the time.

Yeah I went into a few Rumble Pit games but you can check my recent games I was killing other people in the game. I happen to come across my guest and I killed him. I am sorry but I don’t boost maybe the Auto Banhammer thought i was boosting. I am just tired of getting worthless people on my team. Please check out my recent games thank you!

I mean I think you need to have people watching the games and doing the banning instead of a Auto Banhammer.

Those are the cardinal sins, unfortunately. I know whenever the phone rings (or dealing with a family matter) I worry about AFKing and getting a ban…

> Hey This is my first time getting a temp. ban. It says the following: This account has been temp. banned from earning credits. Then says Accounts on this Xbox 360 console has been banned from earning credits.
>
> I am just curious what caused my temp. ban? I played Anniversary Firefight most of the afternoon sometimes getting over 4000 score then jetpacking up and AFKing. I played a few matchmaking games with a AFK guest because I get tired of getting paired up with people who always get in my way or just run out and die all the time.
>
> Yeah I went into a few Rumble Pit games but you can check my recent games I was killing other people in the game. I happen to come across my guest and I killed him. I am sorry but I don’t boost maybe the Auto Banhammer thought i was boosting. I am just tired of getting worthless people on my team. Please check out my recent games thank you!
>
> I mean I think you need to have people watching the games and doing the banning instead of a Auto Banhammer.

For the last 2 days i get a message when I log in saying my console has been temporarily banned and I cannot earn credits. I dont have any clue why this happened is there any way I can find out why.

hello i got banned for 0 kills for some games my little daughter played shes 3 and i put her into rumble pit i shouldnt get banned for this she just likes to play like her daddy so now i have to pay for it which is kinda of stupid if this banhammer is gonna keep this up then i guess i will not play halo anymore

To some limits, I agree. There have been times where Ive been simply overwhelmed, especially early on in my halo gaming experience that I had a few matches with 0 kills. For the most part I still suck, but sometimes, the banhammer seems overly sensitive. There should be some accommodation in regards to a player’s skill/ stats etc.

Why did I get 0 kills? Because I suck that’s why.

So I feel for ya.

> hello i got banned for 0 kills for some games my little daughter played shes 3 and i put her into rumble pit i shouldnt get banned for this she just likes to play like her daddy so now i have to pay for it which is kinda of stupid if this banhammer is gonna keep this up then i guess i will not play halo anymore

i just wish they had taken a little more easier on people and like ive been hearing have a real person ban people not a bot cause the bot isnt always right