Who's talking to Halsey?

In Episode 4, Halsey has a pad and on it the pad it says that they need to talk and asks her how much she knows about the Prometheans. I think this is The Librarian, do you agree? Or do you think it’s someone else?

Holding out hope it may be Chakas. Doubt it though.

One would assume it’s the librarian what with her having set up the Chief, Cortana and the armour development for a specific point in time, there is defiantly a possibility that she would have also set up Halsey to “discover/create” all the things the Librarian had set in motion.

Clearly it’s Johnson from beyond the grave.

I hope its Parangosky CinCONI. That would be cool!

> I hope its Parangosky CinCONI. That would be cool!

I’d sooner see a wooden stake driven through that old bats heart than take orders from her, directly or indirectly.

I believe it may be The Librarian considering she was mentioned in the CGI vid…

I think it’s either the Librarian, a Forerunner AI, or maybe even an Engineer (Floating aliens from ODST).

> Clearly it’s Johnson from beyond the grave.

Aww. I miss Johnson.

the money is on the librarian.
My main question is WHY on earth the didact is contributing to her return.
She meddles to much in his opinion.
OR maybe she holds the key to his return from where ever slip space sent him.

> Holding out hope it may be Chakas. Doubt it though.

That could be possible, seems little silly to include him in the books then have no connection to Halo 4. Personally I wasn’t expecting Halsey, Jul M’dama or The Librarian to appear.

I suspect the Librarian.

I’m secretly hoping its the remnants of Mendicant Bias though, trying to make amends.

> the money is on the librarian.
> My main question is WHY on earth the didact is contributing to her return.
> She meddles to much in his opinion.
> OR maybe she holds the key to his return from where ever slip space sent him.

I think Jul M’dama is in charge now personally. They have yet to give us many hints on weather the Didact lives.

A grenade blew him off. His armor held him together. I don’t think the Didact still lives … at least, he wouldn’t quickly recover from that pulse grenade without his Cryptum.

I suppose it is the guy who talked to Halsey in the Prologue. That is why Halsey asks ‘Ask again, who are you?’

I have a wild theory based on little more than speculation and wishful thinking that it’s a Cortana/Librarian hybrid AI. Hehnce the “It’s complicated” (paraphrased) response to Halsey asking who it is.

Well, now it’s obvious that it was Jul’Mdama. I didn’t expect that at all.

> In Episode 4, Halsey has a pad and on it the pad it says that they need to talk and asks her how much she knows about the Prometheans. I think this is The Librarian, do you agree? Or do you think it’s someone else?

It is Shipmaster Jul 'Mdama.

^^really? after they took that other scientist? lol

> ^^really? after they took that other scientist? lol

i don’t think she knew it was him

I wonder why she is talking to Mdama anyone wanna guess where this will go?