Where is the Constructive Feedback?

I recently compiled a list of solutions to various issues the community has had with Halo 5. However, my in-depth solutions have been repeatedly ignored. Meanwhile forum users continue to insult Halo 5 with absolutely no constructive criticism. The community’s constructive feedback is being overshadowed by non-constructive whining. We can’t expect 343i to listen to us if we don’t provide them with rational solutions to our issues.

Feel free to check out my feedback thread by clicking the link down below. If anyone else has some constructive feedback they would like to share as well please leave a comment with a link to your thread. Thanks.

Link to my feedback thread: https://www.halowaypoint.com/en-us/forums/bee0f457ca024faba8acad15950b4db6/topics/%e2%9a%a0-community-based-feedback-for-halo-5-%e2%9a%a0/50082d43-4dfb-4390-b12d-4bc00561b014/posts

Because when we do provide constructive feedback it get’s ignored. Same reason why we never see Elites in multiplayer in the new trilogy or why we put up with ADS. There’s plenty to complain about but it’s unlikely 343i will make the changes between now, the actual release date since it’s very rare for any developer to do so and well I haven’t seen anything like that happen since the original Half Life, I doubt 343i would rebuild the game from the ground to meet what fans are expecting/wanting.

> 2533274829873463;3:
> Because when we do provide constructive feedback it get’s ignored. Same reason why we never see Elites in multiplayer in the new trilogy or why we put up with ADS. There’s plenty to complain about but it’s unlikely 343i will make the changes between now, the actual release date since it’s very rare for any developer to do so and well I haven’t seen anything like that happen since the original Half Life, I doubt 343i would rebuild the game from the ground to meet what fans are expecting/wanting.

It is true that they won’t build the game from the ground up. Asking for that is unreasonable. However, there are some things that they can still change within the next year. Almost all the solutions I proposed are quite simple to integrate.

> 2533274922858087;4:
> > 2533274829873463;3:
> > Because when we do provide constructive feedback it get’s ignored. Same reason why we never see Elites in multiplayer in the new trilogy or why we put up with ADS. There’s plenty to complain about but it’s unlikely 343i will make the changes between now, the actual release date since it’s very rare for any developer to do so and well I haven’t seen anything like that happen since the original Half Life, I doubt 343i would rebuild the game from the ground to meet what fans are expecting/wanting.
>
>
> It is true that they won’t build the game from the ground up. Asking for that is unreasonable. However, there are some things that they can still change within the next year. Almost all the solutions I proposed are quite simple to integrate.

It’s not unreasonable. But they would probably lose their jobs because the game would have to be delayed even though it works just fine.

If 343 were to actually listen to their audience from the get-go like other communities who are successful, then they would be able to crate the best Halo game in existence. H5 was close, but they kept sprint (which brought along many flaws), added ADS and clamber, and just gave a big middle finger to the competitive community with the “You can toggle it if you don’t like it” comments.

When you want to build the most competitive Halo game to date, but you ignore the advice of the competitive community, you start to get non-constructive feedback. Since 2010, the competitive community has said “no sprint.” Now we get a toggle for customs. Yay. I’ll extend my middle finger back at you too and not buy your game. I’ll stick with my MCC if it ever gets fixed. Otherwise, good bye Halo.

> 2533274829873463;3:
> Because when we do provide constructive feedback it get’s ignored. Same reason why we never see Elites in multiplayer in the new trilogy or why we put up with ADS. There’s plenty to complain about but it’s unlikely 343i will make the changes between now, the actual release date since it’s very rare for any developer to do so and well I haven’t seen anything like that happen since the original Half Life, I doubt 343i would rebuild the game from the ground to meet what fans are expecting/wanting.

The ADS (smart scope) is confirmed to be getting a nerf, and the elites kinda go against equal starts with the whole larger hitboxes and such.

> 2533274829873463;3:
> Because when we do provide constructive feedback it get’s ignored. Same reason why we never see Elites in multiplayer in the new trilogy or why we put up with ADS. There’s plenty to complain about but it’s unlikely 343i will make the changes between now, the actual release date since it’s very rare for any developer to do so and well I haven’t seen anything like that happen since the original Half Life, I doubt 343i would rebuild the game from the ground to meet what fans are expecting/wanting.

The fans of the original Half-life shaped the game/helped the devs rebuild it from the ground up due to feedback?

I remember reading things like that about the sequel (that was also pushed back due to hacks prompting full rebuild), but that must have been impressive, especially in that era, to have an Internet community for a game that hadn’t been released yet.

You guys realize 343 has done things for the community and their vision for Halo? If the feedback blog wasn’t good enough, at least in some level, to show that fan input has been useful in H5’s development, then you’re blatantly ignoring work being done. When you’re that selective with your views of their efforts, you should not be surprised when your views are ignored.

“Where is the constructive feedback?”

Answer: 343 is based in Kirkland, Wasington. After each day, I would imagine 343 Industries follow a standard office cleaning protocol by hired custodians. Assuming 343 closes its doors every night after 5-6pm West-Coast time, the cleaning services most likely collect the waste from the designated holding bins located at each desk. The waste is then transported to a local collection facility within the office building where it sits for the remainder of the week until residential collection services acquires said garbage. The waste is then transported via service truck and then eventually disposed at a separation facility, funded by Waste Management of the City of Kirkland Co. There, garbage is separated from recyclables. After the garbage has been partitioned it will then be transported via freight to the local Washington Disposal Site.

TL;DR:Somewhere near here.

Source: http://www.wmnorthwest.com/kirkland/

> 2533274857398125;6:
> > 2533274829873463;3:
> > Because when we do provide constructive feedback it get’s ignored. Same reason why we never see Elites in multiplayer in the new trilogy or why we put up with ADS. There’s plenty to complain about but it’s unlikely 343i will make the changes between now, the actual release date since it’s very rare for any developer to do so and well I haven’t seen anything like that happen since the original Half Life, I doubt 343i would rebuild the game from the ground to meet what fans are expecting/wanting.
>
>
> The ADS (smart scope) is confirmed to be getting a nerf, and the elites kinda go against equal starts with the whole larger hitboxes and such.

They could do it halo reach style

> 2533274867157068;9:
> > 2533274857398125;6:
> > > 2533274829873463;3:
> > > Because when we do provide constructive feedback it get’s ignored. Same reason why we never see Elites in multiplayer in the new trilogy or why we put up with ADS. There’s plenty to complain about but it’s unlikely 343i will make the changes between now, the actual release date since it’s very rare for any developer to do so and well I haven’t seen anything like that happen since the original Half Life, I doubt 343i would rebuild the game from the ground to meet what fans are expecting/wanting.
> >
> >
> >
> > The ADS (smart scope) is confirmed to be getting a nerf, and the elites kinda go against equal starts with the whole larger hitboxes and such.
>
>
> They could do it halo reach style

Then they would be isolated to one playlist.