> 2533274799400272;8:
> > 2533274831420277;6:
> > Whoever wrote Hunt the Truth needs to write the story for Halo 5. He/she is excellent, whereas the man who wrote Halo 5 and Spartan Ops is awful.
> >
> > Also, more than three missions of Blue Team. Lots more.
>
>
> I wouldn’t judge him so harshly. I like to compare him with David S. Goyer, has some interesting ideas, but needs supervision from time to time to get the execution right.
>
> I also find it odd that he seems to have some sort of weird fascination with monitors. Those things always end up saving the day in his Halo stories because of reasons.
I found the names. Brian Reed wrote Halo 5 and Spartan Ops. Chris Schlerf wrote Halo 4. Noah Eichen wrote Hunt the Truth.
I think Halo 5 was really poorly written. The main villain was a stereotypical “Evil AI”, created by a stereotypical “Turn to the Dark Side”, who wanted to do evil for “The Greater Good”. It was also a character who was meant to be dead, having just had a touching, emotional death scene at the end of Halo 4. The other villain, the Warden Eternal, wasn’t particularly interesting either. Of all the other characters, only Buck (Joseph Staten’s creation) and Exuberant Witness were interesting.
Noah Eichen, on the other hand, has interesting ideas. In Hunt the Truth, he wove an interesting story, packed full of mysteries. The start of the series, with conflicting accounts and the resulting mystery, was wonderful. Then, Ben’s quest to bring down ONI was great, with ONI always being two steps ahead, with there always being a twist waiting around the corner. During all of this, there was also the mystery about Master Chief on Biko. It was excellently written.
Chris Schlerf did far better in Halo 4 than Reed in Halo 5. He explored Cortana’s character, and her descent into madness and rampancy, really well, before giving her a memorable, heroic sacrifice of a death. Nothing Reed did with her was really new, because Schlerf had already looked into her mind, and her rampancy. Master Chief’s character was also dealt with far better in Halo 4, although this could be because Master Chief gets barely any screentime in Halo 5.
And we all know how amazing Joseph Staten’s original trilogy, ODST, and Contact Harvest were.
In my opinion, Brian Reed deserves to lose his role as the writer of Halo 6, and it should be given to Noah Eichen, or returned to Chris Schlerf. Reed can stay around to write Exuberant Witness’ dialogue, because she was perfect.