Personally I like High Noon and Ridgeline the best.
Battle Canyon is great for nostalgia as is Breakneck and Penance is just ehh.
Solitary is interesting…I go back and forth on the merits of that map. I feel like Sword Base is that map evolved for Reach so it feels a little unnecessary, but very pretty.
I like Solitary, but once you get high enough, there is so much cover that there is no real reason to stay there. The sniper rifles are very limited in what they can achieve, and for a lousy sniper like me it’s not worth it to grab them.
Breakneck is loads of fun. Elite Slayer and 1 Flag are so much fun to play. Multiflag and normal BTB slayer… eh. I dunno why.
Battle Canyon is frantic, which sometimes is good and sometimes is bad. It is also really small, even on Reach’s movement settings. On Anniversary… I’m walking into walls all the time, it’s so small.
I absolutely love Ridgeline. This is what we should have got instead of Hemmorhage. So much better, so much faster. No getting cross-mapped. And there’s a laser in the middle. Dreams come true.
Penance is my personal favorite, but if you don’t have the jetpack it can be tougher. It doesn’t break the map by any means, but jetpack users do have an advantage.