What is Actually Canon from Reach?

I’ll certain this has been asked a thousand times. I’m just not sure what to consider canon at this point with respect to the Reach timeline.

We’ve seen great material in the books and graphic novels which, for the most part, line up. Cortana wasn’t on the planet Reach, the Autumn never touched down on the planet, the Spartans all died fighting for the generators, there was no secret Covenant invasion that we know of. However, the game claims that the Autumn was on the planet, Cortana was as well, and the Covenant had been on Reach for a month before it was completely glassed.

Even if there was a secret invasion fleet, shouldn’t the defense grid have ripped it to shreds? Wouldn’t some civilian transport noticed them?

Why did the S-IIIs have energy shields when it was new when the Master Chief got his new armor just prior to the invasion? How could Dr. Halsey have been present for both the armor fitting and the events at Sword Base?

These are the main questions I’ve has since the game came out, as it seemed like Bungie deliberately said ‘forget canon, we’re done here anyway’ and threw everything out the window. Hopefully someone can answer these for me without some handwaving.

I’ve heard things even along the lines of “Reach is canon, but it’s more of a propaganda piece rather than a historical account.”. I feel like explanations like this are convenient ways of making the game fit in the universe when it doesn’t fit with the established lore. Any thoughts or answers?

I worship the novels too bro. The short and Curlys of the game is that Bungie simply did whatever the hell they wanted which was within their right. The end result was mediocre in my opinion and failed to evoke a sense of doom and urgency like the novels did. SIIIs were a nice touch, but that’s really all I liked. Story wise it was as bland as can be.

I won’t lie, the story was OK (I can’t remember half of it despite heavily playing it almost every day for a year), so that adds into your ‘blandness’ statement. I guess I ultimately have to agree.

What just doesn’t make sense to me is how 343’s media (Fall of Reach comics) backs up the original novel events, then the 2010 definitive novel attempts to justify parts of Halo: Reach (game). Everywhere you read (Halopedia, Halo wiki, etc) tend to separate out the two storylines as if they’re in different universes. We can’t get a solid grasp on the true story or timeline of events.

I was hoping maybe we could get an answer from Catalog, perhaps.

> 2548688896268500;3:
> I won’t lie, the story was OK (I can’t remember half of it despite heavily playing it almost every day for a year), so that adds into your ‘blandness’ statement. I guess I ultimately have to agree.
>
> What just doesn’t make sense to me is how 343’s media (Fall of Reach comics) backs up the original novel events, then the 2010 definitive novel attempts to justify parts of Halo: Reach (game). Everywhere you read (Halopedia, Halo wiki, etc) tend to separate out the two storylines as if they’re in different universes. We can’t get a solid grasp on the true story or timeline of events.
>
> I was hoping maybe we could get an answer from Catalog, perhaps.

It’s a mess. They are in fact, all different retellings of the same origin story. 343i uses many elements from past novels. Blue team from FoR, shield worlds from GoO, Forerunner lore from Greg Bears trilogy. Bungie took Nothing from the novels, but like I said…fanboys are happy as clams and get irritated and threAtened when you challenge or even question their deities.

> 2548688896268500;1:
> I’ll certain this has been asked a thousand times. I’m just not sure what to consider canon at this point with respect to the Reach timeline.
>
> We’ve seen great material in the books and graphic novels which, for the most part, line up. Cortana wasn’t on the planet Reach, the Autumn never touched down on the planet, the Spartans all died fighting for the generators, there was no secret Covenant invasion that we know of. However, the game claims that the Autumn was on the planet, Cortana was as well, and the Covenant had been on Reach for a month before it was completely glassed.
>
> Even if there was a secret invasion fleet, shouldn’t the defense grid have ripped it to shreds? Wouldn’t some civilian transport noticed them?
>
> Why did the S-IIIs have energy shields when it was new when the Master Chief got his new armor just prior to the invasion? How could Dr. Halsey have been present for both the armor fitting and the events at Sword Base?
>
> These are the main questions I’ve has since the game came out, as it seemed like Bungie deliberately said ‘forget canon, we’re done here anyway’ and threw everything out the window. Hopefully someone can answer these for me without some handwaving.
>
> I’ve heard things even along the lines of “Reach is canon, but it’s more of a propaganda piece rather than a historical account.”. I feel like explanations like this are convenient ways of making the game fit in the universe when it doesn’t fit with the established lore. Any thoughts or answers?

All but one of these discrepancies have been explained, most of them by the Data Drop. The most important take-away is that ONI (the same ONI that made Onyx disappear) manipulated WINTER CONTINGENCY to keep virtually the entire planet (both civilian and under-clearanced military) in the dark about the invasion, especially those assigned to Operation: RED FLAG. Admiral Parangosky and Vice Admiral Stanforth deliberately withheld effective counterattacks in the hope that the Covenant would bring an assault carrier or supercarrier into low orbit: The Spartan-IIs would then board the ship and commence RED FLAG as intended. Operation: UPPER CUT inadvertently threw that plan out the window when Long Night of Solace was destroyed.

Bungie themselves retconned Mark V’s original issue date from August 29, 2552 to November 24, 2551. The 2011 version of the Halo Encyclopedia later clarified that the 2551 version of the Mark V is the Mark V (B), which introduced energy shields but couldn’t accommodate an AI. This is what the Spartan-IIs wore until 8/29/52 and what the members of Noble Team wore (in various configurations) throughout their time on Reach. It’s why Noble Six couldn’t just plug Cortana’s chip into his helmet.

Reach has a 27-hour day. The Mark V test took place early in the morning. “The Package” begins at 26:16 hours (close to midnight). Halsey would have plenty of time to get from the Highland Mountains to SWORD Base. On a related note, the “Cortana” that Noble Six delivered to the Autumn was just a “dumb” fragment that Halsey had used to study the crashed Forerunner ship under the Babd Catha Ice Shelf. Her primary incarnation was exactly where the book says she was.

The Fall of Reach comic series is only semi-canon. The same can be said for “Palace Hotel” from Halo Evolutions. The core stories are the same but they diverge significantly at other points.

The one issue that hasn’t been addressed officially (though it’s very simple to work out) is the Autumn being ground-side. Rather than jumping out of the system at 0647 hours, the ship went groundside (because Dr. Halsey told Captain Keyes of her discovery) and remained there until roughly 1715 hours. Yeah, this one’s an outright (albeit minor) retcon.

> 2548688896268500;1:
> I’ll certain this has been asked a thousand times. I’m just not sure what to consider canon at this point with respect to the Reach timeline.
> We’ve seen great material in the books and graphic novels which, for the most part, line up. Cortana wasn’t on the planet Reach, the Autumn never touched down on the planet, the Spartans all died fighting for the generators, there was no secret Covenant invasion that we know of. However, the game claims that the Autumn was on the planet, Cortana was as well, and the Covenant had been on Reach for a month before it was completely glassed.
>
>
> Explained in Halsey’s journal as Cortana being split into two fragments. One onboard the Autumn and another deciphering the Sword Base artifact. The Autumn touching down for the emergency pick up after the events Gamma Station were rectonned in with adjunct stories and data drops reinforcing this notion. The group of Spartans composing the hastily retasked Red Team (Beta-Red) did all die or go unaccounted while defending the generators. This has not changed from First Strike.
>
> Even if there was a secret invasion fleet, shouldn’t the defense grid have ripped it to shreds? Wouldn’t some civilian transport noticed them?
>
> The grid was positioned on the other side of the planet. The Holomap onboard the Corvette seems to indicate as much back when the game first came out. Since then more assets like the data drops as well as Halo:Fleet Battles expanded on why the orbital defense grid stayed intact for so long while the Fleet of Valiant Prudence did its thing.
>
> Why did the S-IIIs have energy shields when it was new when the Master Chief got his new armor just prior to the invasion? How could Dr. Halsey have been present for both the armor fitting and the events at Sword Base?
>
> This was explained by Bungie even before Reach came out. Mark V armor had already been issued to those already available on Reach. Not all S-IIIs received the armor, but those S-IIIs deemed worthy by Kurt and Mendez were transferred out of their respective companies into more specialized fireteams like Noble and received the proper equipment of S-IIs. Halsey never personally fit Noble Team and didn’t know about the Spartan III project during the events of Halo:Reach. Though obviously considering how only humans with Spartan levels of augmentation can use MJOLNIR she was able to easily deduce that Noble Team was comprised of Spartans made from some unknown project. As for the Master Chief, he was away on constant missions not having time for a refit until returning to Reach. The significance of the Chief’s armor fitting was that he was the known test subject to demonstrate the effectiveness of an onboard AI on the Mark V suit.
>
> These are the main questions I’ve has since the game came out, as it seemed like Bungie deliberately said ‘forget canon, we’re done here anyway’ and threw everything out the window. Hopefully someone can answer these for me without some handwaving.
> I’ve heard things even along the lines of “Reach is canon, but it’s more of a propaganda piece rather than a historical account.”. I feel like explanations like this are convenient ways of making the game fit in the universe when it doesn’t fit with the established lore. Any thoughts or answers?

Long story short, aside from the really obvious retcon of having the Autumn turn back and land on Reach after the Gamma Station mission and generators being compromised, most of the oddities have already been explained away. Some having been covered for longer than others. Halo: Fleet Battles is the most recent addition of lore to further explain things away to help integrate Halo:Reach’s place easier.

With the upcoming Fall of Reach web series, there will probably be even more exposition to integrate the Fall of Reach side of things with Halo:Reach, but more likely than not the main focus will probably be updating and making consistent how events looked visually such as which S-II wore what armor at the time, etc. which would override the visuals of the Graphic Novel adaptation.

> 2533274900126904;5:
> > 2548688896268500;1:
> > I’ll certain this has been asked a thousand times. I’m just not sure what to consider canon at this point with respect to the Reach timeline.
> >
> > We’ve seen great material in the books and graphic novels which, for the most part, line up. Cortana wasn’t on the planet Reach, the Autumn never touched down on the planet, the Spartans all died fighting for the generators, there was no secret Covenant invasion that we know of. However, the game claims that the Autumn was on the planet, Cortana was as well, and the Covenant had been on Reach for a month before it was completely glassed.
> >
> > Even if there was a secret invasion fleet, shouldn’t the defense grid have ripped it to shreds? Wouldn’t some civilian transport noticed them?
> >
> > Why did the S-IIIs have energy shields when it was new when the Master Chief got his new armor just prior to the invasion? How could Dr. Halsey have been present for both the armor fitting and the events at Sword Base?
> >
> > These are the main questions I’ve has since the game came out, as it seemed like Bungie deliberately said ‘forget canon, we’re done here anyway’ and threw everything out the window. Hopefully someone can answer these for me without some handwaving.
> >
> > I’ve heard things even along the lines of “Reach is canon, but it’s more of a propaganda piece rather than a historical account.”. I feel like explanations like this are convenient ways of making the game fit in the universe when it doesn’t fit with the established lore. Any thoughts or answers?
>
>
> All but one of these discrepancies have been explained, most of them by the Data Drop. The most important take-away is that ONI (the same ONI that made Onyx disappear) manipulated WINTER CONTINGENCY to keep virtually the entire planet (both civilian and under-clearanced military) in the dark about the invasion, especially those assigned to Operation: RED FLAG. Admiral Parangosky and Vice Admiral Stanforth deliberately withheld effective counterattacks in the hope that the Covenant would bring an assault carrier or supercarrier into low orbit: The Spartan-IIs would then board the ship and commence RED FLAG as intended. Operation: UPPER CUT inadvertently threw that plan out the window when Long Night of Solace was destroyed.
>
> Bungie themselves retconned Mark V’s original issue date from August 29, 2552 to November 24, 2551. The 2011 version of the Halo Encyclopedia later clarified that the 2551 version of the Mark V is the Mark V (B), which introduced energy shields but couldn’t accommodate an AI. This is what the Spartan-IIs wore until 8/29/52 and what the members of Noble Team wore (in various configurations) throughout their time on Reach. It’s why Noble Six couldn’t just plug Cortana’s chip into his helmet.
>
> Reach has a 27-hour day. The Mark V test took place early in the morning. “The Package” begins at 26:16 hours (close to midnight). Halsey would have plenty of time to get from the Highland Mountains to SWORD Base. On a related note, the “Cortana” that Noble Six delivered to the Autumn was just a “dumb” fragment that Halsey had used to study the crashed Forerunner ship under the Babd Catha Ice Shelf. Her primary incarnation was exactly where the book says she was.
>
> The Fall of Reach comic series is only semi-canon. The same can be said for “Palace Hotel” from Halo Evolutions. The core stories are the same but they diverge significantly at other points.
>
> The one issue that hasn’t been addressed officially (though it’s very simple to work out) is the Autumn being ground-side. Rather than jumping out of the system at 0647 hours, the ship went groundside (because Dr. Halsey told Captain Keyes of her discovery) and remained there until roughly 1715 hours. Yeah, this one’s an outright (albeit minor) retcon.

That entire passage just blew my mind.

I do call bull on the ‘Halsey having ample time to move back and forth,’ as the base was overrun by Covenant forces. However, wow. I didn’t realize we had these documents.

I also didn’t think the Autumn was rated for atmosphere, so it wouldn’t have been able to land. I suppose I can get past that, though. Minor plot point they left out. Wow.

I am curious as to why you say the Fall of Reach comics are “semi-canon;” I don’t remember reading anything significantly divergent beyond the Mark V(b) being earlier than shown in the comic (IE: comic is essentially the same as the original book, from what I remember).

Maybe the Fall of Reach animated thing they’re releasing will attempt to clear this up rather than muddy the waters.

I probably should have elaborated when I said 'Cortana wasn’t on the planet." I kind of knew that already, it is more of “why did we need her to be in two fragments?” That’s something else I fail to understand. Did Cortana get Halo’s location from the Reach artifact? I thought it came from the crystal obtained on Cote d’Azur? Long story short, why did we even need to have two Cortana fragments? Just to throw her into Reach?

> 2548688896268500;8:
> I probably should have elaborated when I said 'Cortana wasn’t on the planet." I kind of knew that already, it is more of “why did we need her to be in two fragments?” That’s something else I fail to understand. Did Cortana get Halo’s location from the Reach artifact? I thought it came from the crystal obtained on Cote d’Azur? Long story short, why did we even need to have two Cortana fragments? Just to throw her into Reach?

Dr. Halsey’s journal reveals that she and Cortana mistook the contents of the Cote d’Azur artifact for some kind of language. After being reunited with her fragment (which contained the data from the SWORD Base relic) Cortana realized the “language” was actually a star chart. From a design standpoint, though? Yeah, Bungie just wanted Cortana to be in the campaign.

I agree that Halsey getting from the FLEETCOM complex to SWORD Base is a bit of a stretch. In fact, I brought it up in the first draft of my original post. Granted, it’s not impossible for her to get back in (SWORD must have had multiple secret entrances) but an official clarification would be nice.

> 2548688896268500;8:
> I probably should have elaborated when I said 'Cortana wasn’t on the planet." I kind of knew that already, it is more of “why did we need her to be in two fragments?” That’s something else I fail to understand. Did Cortana get Halo’s location from the Reach artifact? I thought it came from the crystal obtained on Cote d’Azur? Long story short, why did we even need to have two Cortana fragments? Just to throw her into Reach?

Halsey needed an AI to analyze the artifact and apparently only Cortana had the skill set to do so. To this day it’s still has not been specified what sort of practical data was in the Sword Base artifact. One could presume that the coordinates for Halo still came from the Cote d’Azur artifact but were undecipherable whilst the knowledge from the Sword Base artifact could have helped shed light in that regard. But that’s mere conjecture…

Edit: No wait that was indeed factually covered in Halsey’s journal. To quote for reference:

August 24th entry which was about the Cote d’Azur artifact:
“I’ve hypothesiszed that the language/code, and hence the object, derives from predecessors of the Covenant, or from an unknown, more ancient alien culture. Deciphering the message on the object, however eludes me for the moment. A more definitive analysis certain requires the actual object and all relevant etiological data.”

August 27th entry:

“Cortana (parts of her anyway) continues to learn and decipher the alien protoculture language, code forms, and hopefully technologies. She’ll continue to update her separated portion until the very last possible moment.”


So yeah, does seem more concrete that the fragment’s sole purpose was to analyze the Sword Base artifact to have the basis for understanding Forerunner language and codes like that on the Cote d’Azur artifact.

Hopefully this helps. It’s unofficial, but it does put events into perspective.

July 17th-18th:
– Battle of Sigma Octanus IV
– UNSC Iroquois compromised by Covenant Telemetry Probe*

Halo: The Fall of Reach (2010 Edition) Page 247

The object opened a single photo eye and gazed at the stars, collecting data to reference its current position. It would continue to do this for several days. During that time, it would slowly build up a charge. When it reached critical energy, a tiny sliver of thallium nitride memory crystal would be ejected at nearly the speed of light and a minute Slipstream field would generate around it. If its trajectory was perfect, it would intercept a Covenant receiver located at precise coordinates in the alternate space… and the tiny automated probe would reveal to the Covenant every place the Iroquois had been.

*Sometime between July 18th and July 23rd the UNSC Iroquois returns to Epsilon Eridani, unknowingly informing the Covenant of the system’s location and importance. Doctor Halsey’s Journal however mentions that Battle Group Leviathan and the UNSC Iroquois didn’t return to Reach until August 12th. This could possibly contradict Data Drop Five in which Admiral Stanforth informs Admiral Parangosky that he has arrived at Epsilon Eridani on August 1st. Of course he only brought half of his Battle Group at the time which could mean that the rest of the group, including the UNSC Iroquois, returned to Reach later on the 12th as Halsey mentioned.

The UNSC Iroquois arriving on August 12th still presents a problem however, as Covenant forces appeared on Reach as early as July 23rd, which would mean they discovered the Epsilon Eridani system long before the UNSC Iroquois ever arrived. One possible explanation could be that the Telemetry Probe did not require the Iroquois to actually enter the system in order for the Covenant to find it. The Probe could have instead studied the vessel’s location following her mandatory series of random slipspace jumps and then determined the ships most logical destination based on their own understanding of that area of space.

This is not beyond the realm of possibility as the Covenant would use this very tactic when they tracked the stolen Destroyer Bloodied Spirit to the Zeta Doradus System, as seen in Halo: Ghosts of Onyx.

July 19th
– Admiral Parangosky sends message to Admiral Stanforth about initiating Operation: RED FLAG.

Data Drop Three – Admiral Parangosky

We’ve run some numbers based on the Covenant’s movement pattern over the last nine months and the results are… well, not good. Epsilon Eridani is at 87.2% probability of intersect within the next five months. Eight-seven percent. It’s never been that high. I think we need to start seriously considering RED FLAG.

July 23rd:
– Visegrád Relay disabled
– Reach loses contact with outer colonies
– UNSC Marines sent to investigate

Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal July 23rd, 2552

Contact lost with Visegrád communication relay hub. Not a malfunction. That relay had a level-5 communication package installed prior to contact with the Covennat. Years back when insurgents had secretly infiltrated Reach (before Operation: CLEAN SWEEP), we hardened our communications network. The hub was designed to withstand internal and external sabotage. Considering the urgency in Dr. Sorvad’s last message and his demand for secrecy, I believe this is more than coincidence. This list of possibilities is short – all are unpleasant.

  1. Internal subterfuge, perhaps from another Section 3 or Beta 5 project. But to what end?
  2. Insurgent action; no laughing matter if somehow this silence means the start of a larger attack exactly when we don’t need that distraction.
  3. Covenant… the depth of their technology hasn’t been plumbed at all, and if somehow the Cole Protocol has been breached…?!

The Vice Admiral was already aware we lost the hub and had personnel addressing the situation. I mentioned the vital staff I have in the area, and expressed my thoughts on the possible cause. Vice Admiral shared my concerns and promised to let me know when my people were located.”

July 24th:
– Contact lost with UNSC Marines
– NOBLE Team sent to investigate
– Covenant forces encountered in Visegrád
– Winter Contingency declared

(Reach – Winter Contingency)

Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal – July 24th, 2552

Caught a rumor that a special forces unit was sent to investigate the hub and that this team, too, has disappeared. Apparently a second team will be sent to Visegrád, but nobody can tell me what this second team is. Details on this operation are unusually sparse (can’t even determine what branch of the UNSC the unit serves in).
Learned that this second unit is dubbed “NOBLE Team.” Will follow up on that ASAP.

Meanwhile, receiving scattered data from the usual suspects concerning atmospheric anomalies along with radar and slipspace monitoring glitches. Compared these events to those recorded near Sigma Octanus. No match. Still, a series of coincidences usually aren’t coincidence.

July 26th:
– A single Covenant Corvette assaults SWORD Base and is destroyed by MAC Round.
– Dr. Halsey debriefs NOBLE Team on the events that occurred at Visegrád.

(Reach – Sword Base)

Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal July 26th, 2552

More pressing right now is the discovery that Covenant Zealots were behind the hub’s destruction. That they are here is almost anticlimactic to me. What other logical explanation was there? Still, the enemy on Reach… Security measures are under way to preserve our discoveries here and more importantly, integrate and update Cortana with the latest intelligence from the site before Operation: RED FLAG.

And I finally confirmed my suspicions about NOBLE itself, as incomprehensible as this news is. They are Spartan – and with one exception, they’re clearly not mine.
Even more intriguing are the others on this NOBLE Team. They are considerably younger than Jorge. The way these others move… they’re obviously augmented. Are they all Spartan-IIs? Or as I suspect from their inelegant personas, are they substandard versions of the Spartan-II? Perhaps from a parallel program (JAVELIN), or some next gen venture piggybacking on the last three decades of my work.

July 27th-August 10th:
– No enemy activity detected*

*This is an assumption based on the fact that Halo Reach completely skips over this time as there are no levels between SWORD Base, (July 26th), and Nightfall, (August 11th). Doctor Halsey’s Journal also makes no references to any Covenant activity during this time.

August 1st:
– Admiral Stanforth returns to Epsilon Eridani with half his battle group and responds to Admiral Parangosky’s proposal. Reach may be used as a sacrifice to lure in the Covenant only if the Covenant have already discovered the planet.

Data Drop Four – Admiral Stanforth

COLLATERAL: The need for a Class-Five is paramount to the success of this operation, but it would likely require the sacrifice of a colony of significant value to the Covenant, potentially one with a high accretion of alien artifacts of non-Covenant origin, such as the volumes recorded on Harvest, Meridian, Arcadia, or even Reach. We would have to lower our defenses, draw the enemy in, and then acquire transport by force.

ADDENDUM: Margaret, my original notes did include Reach here, but this was only a hypothetical and based entirely on what we’ve found there. You should keep in mind that using Reach as bait for this op is not an option I’m willing to consider. It’s tactical suicide. We’d be giving them the war with only Earth left to fall back to, something I will not endorse. The only exception to this, in my mind, would be if the Covenant had already located Reach and it was deemed indefensible.

August 3rd:
– Cortana chosen for RED FLAG
– Dr. Halsey splits Cortana into two fragments

Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal August 3rd, 2552

Cortana and I have discussed this at length, and she concurs it is the only logical procedure. Spartan-117 and his team require her expertise for their mission, which I believe will be our last real opportunity at finding an end to the war. She will be invaluable to them in their mission to penetrate Covenant territory and deliver a decapitating blow to their hierarchy.
Cortana, however, is also the best-suited AI on Reach to analyze the symbols and operating systems in Professor Sorvad’s site. The solomonic solution that we arrived at independently is to divide her.
I’ll copy most of her IEP translation routines to an independent module. Meanwhile, the incarnate Cortana will continue with John and Blue Team. Both operations are critical to the war effort. If Laszlo made a breakthrough, that data would aid Blue Team in enemy space. The severed data-mining portion of Cortana can then be reunited and she can update herself before Blue Team departs.
Both operations are critical to the war effort.

August 11th:
– Covenant forces reappear in greater numbers
– Recon teams deployed*

(Reach – Nightfall)

*A date is not officially given for the level Nightfall, however Kat-B320 mentions that the, “Sun will be up in a few hours…and it’s going to be a very busy day” which would seemingly imply that Nightfall begins before Reach midnight, (26:30 Hours), on the 11th and ends a few hours before sunrise on the 12th. The UNSC begins the assault on the Covenant at 08:00 Hours August 12th.

August 12th:
– Spartan IIs return to Reach
– UNSC Iroquois returns to Reach
– Halsey and Keyes discuss RED FLAG
– Halsey speaks with John-117
– UNSC Army engages Covenant forces in Viery Territory

Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal August 12th, 2552

Went much better than I had imagined. We talked about Miranda, his ‘Keyes Loop,’ the Spartans and RED FLAG (what little I could prematurely disclose). We parted well, wishing each other the best on our respective missions. I offered my hand for him to shake. He kissed me on the cheek. As I said… ever the gentleman.
Next was my visit with John. We had just a few minutes groundside at Camp Hathcock. I told him of the coming procedures (gave his head a cursory MRI; surgical site is acceptable), and that he had a new mission soon.

(Reach – Tip of the Spear)

August 14th:
– UNSC Air Force assault Covenant Supercarrier Long Night of Solace
– LNoS is destroyed with a makeshift Slipspace bomb
– Jorge-052 is killed
– Covenant reinforcements arrive

Data Drop Five – Admiral Stanforth

Holland’s informed me that the only [CLASS-FIVE CSO] they’ve confirmed, a vessel called “LONG NIGHT OF SOLACE,” was dropped just outside of New Alexandria a few days ago. That could have been ours if SpecWar wasn’t so damn trigger happy. Now we’ll just have to wait, pull the Covenant in deep enough to bring the damn trap down right on top of them.

(Reach – Long Night of Solace)

August 23rd:
– UNSC forces. including NOBLE Team, engage Covenant in New Alexandria*
– Dr. Halsey requests NOBLE Team to meet her at SWORD Base†
– Catherine-B320 is killed

*During the final cutscene of New Alexandria Jun-A266 references a rumor stating that “Gauntlet, Red and Echo Teams” are assisting with planetary evacuation. It was never confirmed if this was the case however and it was never explained which Spartan branch these teams supposedly belonged to or if they were Spartans at all. It is believed by some that Red Team is a reference to the Spartan-II Red Team which appeared in Halo: The Fall of Reach and Halo: First Strike. This is impossible however as the Spartans of that team were actually a part of Blue Team at this time and were not split and designated Red Team by the Master Chief until August 30th.
It’s possible this team was a separate group of Spartan-IIs as there is an inconsistency with the number of active Spartan-IIs during this time. The whereabouts of Naomi-010 during the Fall of Reach for example has never been established. It could be that Gauntlet, Red and Echo Teams were made up of Spartan-IIs and Spartan-III working in unison. The Halo 4: Essential Visual Guide does make reference to squads of Spartan-IIs and IIIs who fought on the planet Tribute, which was one of several other planets in the Epsilon Eridani system under attack.

†NOBLE Team was ordered to Sword Base for a “Torch and burn op“, however Dr. Halsey informs them that that mission was just a pretext to bring them to her.

(Reach – Exodus / New Alexandria)

August 24th:
– Dr. Halsey momentarily examines holographic image of a mysterious crystal found on Sigma Octanus.
Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal August 24th, 2552

Curiously, the object, embedded in a stone fragment, shares many of the iconic language/code forms we discovered at the xenoarcheological site under SWORD Base. From this supplemental data (which I couldn’t copy and had to replicate from memory), I’ve hypothesized that the language/code, and hence the object, derives from predecessors of the Covenant, or from an unknown, more ancient alien culture. Deciphering the message on the object, however, eludes me for the moment. A more definitive analysis certainly requires the actual object and all relevant etiological data.

August 25th:
– Captain Jacob Keyes chosen for RED FLAG
– John-117 chosen to work with Cortana on RED FLAG
– UNSC Pillar of Autumn chosen for RED FLAG*
– Cortana and Halsey discuss the Sigma Octanus Crystal

Halo: The Fall of Reach (2010 Edition) Page 266 – 267

This frozen signal contains information that matches the sample from Sigma Octanus Four.’ Cortana sighed and her shoulders slumped. ‘Unfortunately, all my attempts at translating the code have failed…so far.’
‘Your conclusions, Cortana?’ Dr. Halsey reminded her.
‘Insufficient data for complete analysis, Doctor.’
‘Hypothesize.’
Cortana bit her lower lip. ‘There are two possibilities. The data originates from the Covenant or another alien race.’ She frowned. ‘If it’s another alien species, the Covenant probably wants these artifacts to scavenge their technology. Either conclusion opens several new opportunities for the NavSpecWep-

Data Drop Five – Admiral Stanforth

Keyes

At the end of the day, there are half a dozen CO’s we could easily slot here, but there’s only one who I’d trust with my life and that’s Keyes. Having worked with him several times over the last decade, I can attest to his innate prowess in astrogation and naval warfare, but more importantly, the man is just plain fearless. I would definitely use “reckless” to describe anyone who I’d thought fit the bill, but I’ve found no fault in his tactics. He’s handled some things that even I can’t really quantify or explain, most recently the “Loop” deal at Sigma Octanus IV.
He’d have been the first name on my list if I was the one making it.

John 117

Looking at his CSV en total, my first thought is that this is fabricated. His service record reads like a career composite of three full Tier-1/L5 ODST squads, back to back for
two and a half decades. Dear God, active in 207 ground engagements and those are just the ones that we’re able to file on record. If I wasn’t on line to approve his deployment for these, again and again, I wouldn’t believe any of it. And he’s just one of the SPARTAN-II assets we’ll have onboard, there’s 25 of them being recalled for this op, all from a multitude of theaters, some even being pulled directly from combat.

Pillar of Autumn

Not terribly surprised at this selection due the over-bulked, overmassed honeycomb interstitial framework. It’s ironic, I suppose, that the same absurd design that forced this ship into the scrap yard years ago is resurrecting it for RED FLAG. A cruiser was an obvious choice, as noted in my prelim, but the reason she opted for a Halcyon – this particular Halcyon, in fact – is because it can take an incredible beating without suffering functional compromise far longer than any other ships we current field. She might be slow and cumbersome, but she’s a real beast, especially now that they’ve tweaked her armament. Good choice.
If that doesn’t scream last resort, I don’t know what does.

*While Cortana explains that her final choice is the Pillar of Autumn on August 25th, there is a note in Halsey’s Journal dated August 3rd which says “I hope the Autumn is refitted in time” which suggests the Autumn was already in the process of being refitted before Cortana made her final decision. This is either a discrepancy or Halsey already knew the Autumn was going to be chosen, (and ordered its refit as soon as possible), because she and Cortana are so much alike.

August 26th:
– NOBLE Team extracted from New Alexandria

August 27th:
– Spartan IIs informed of RED FLAG
– Cortana continues to learn and decipher the alien proto-culture language, code forms and technologies

Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal August 27th, 2525

Cortana (parts of her anyway) continues to learn and decipher the alien protoculture language, code forms, and hopefully technologies. She’ll continue to update her separated portion until the very last possible moment.

August 29th:
– Master Chief trains with his Cortana fragment*
– Dr. Halsey returns to SWORD Base†
– NOBLE Team returns to SWORD Base
– Cortana chooses Noble Six as her escort

Halo: The Fall of Reach (2010 Edition) Page 280

The firing range was uncharacteristically quiet. Normally, the air would be filled with noise – the sharp, staccato crackle of automatic-weapons fire; the urgent yells of soldiers practicing combat operations; and the barked, curse-laden orders of drill instructors. John frowned as he guided the Warthog to the security checkpoint.
The silence on the combat range was somehow unsettling.
Even more unsettling were the extra security personnel; today, there were three times the normal number of MPs patrolling the gate.

*The Master Chief makes note that the training facility seemed “eerily silent” which could mean that no one was there to train as they were busy engaging the enemy for real elsewhere on the Planet. He also makes note that security was much more tight with “three times the number of MPs patrolling“. This heightened security could be because the enemy is on Reach but not yet near those facilities.

†Evidence suggests Halsey was able to return to SWORD Base on the 29th because she had a Military escort. Troopers were alive and “committed to the position“, which was the entrance to Halsey’s lab. There were also “Others” who handled the demolition which means there was some other team working in unison with Noble. ODSTs? Other Spartans? This is unknown at this point but we do know they complete their mission as well as secure Halsey’s Journal. Halsey also says she “requires no escort” possibly because she already knew someone else was there to assist her. Jun is ordered to go with her anyways.

(Reach – The Package)

August 30th:
– The Pillar of Autumn receives word Reach is under attack
– Fermion station detects Covenant fleet inbound for Eridani system.
– PoA lands and secures Cortana fragment from NOBLE Team
– The Fleet of Particular Justice assaults Reach
– Pillar of Autumn engages Covenant fleet.
– Spartans deployed to Reach
– Carter-A259 is killed
– Emile-A239 is killed
– Cortana is made whole again and with her knowledge she sets a course for Alpha Halo
– Spartan-B312 is killed

(Reach – The Pillar of Autumn / Lone Wolf)

Doctor Halsey’s Personal Journal August 30th, 2552

The Covenant on Reach. NOT a scout party; they are here en masse. I’ve seen the reports of how ‘contained’ the situation is – military shorthand for ‘it’-Yoink!- the fan’.

Halo: The Fall of Reach (2010 Edition) Page 375 -376

ONI reports on the symbols found in the anomalous rock had defied cryptoanalysis. Keyes’ order to plot a navigation route sparked a connection between the data; she accessed the alien symbols and rather than compare them with alphabets or hieroglyphics, compared them to star formations.
There were some startling similarities – along with a number of differences. Cortana reanalyzed the symbols and accounted for thousands of years of stellar drift.
A tenth of a second later she had a close match on her charts – 86.2 percent.
Interesting. Perhaps the markings in the rock recovered on Sigma Octanus IV were navigation symbols, albeit highly unusual and stylized ones – mathematical symbols as artistic and elegant as Chinese calligraphy.
What was there that the Covenant wanted so badly that they had launched a full offensive against Sigma Octanus IV? Whatever it was… Cortana was interested, too.

September 19th:
– The Pillar of Autumn arrives at Alpha Halo

All I can really say is wow. I’ve read all of those sources (with the exeption of the data drop) but it’s been so long. I never put the dots together but that’s a little more problematic without the data drop portion. I’ll keep pondering over this, but I suppose it all makes sense. Some of it seems a little forced but I guess 343 had to make sense of what was thrown into their laps. And they did a good job.

Thanks to everyone for your responses. Your explanations are awesome, and I appreciate you citing your sources, Nihilus & Tzu.

Nihilus, thanks again for taking the time to post the above timeline. Realize that must have taken a while and I do appreciate it! I think they should make you (un)official Lore Master!

Halo cannon on YouTube, can’t link I’m on mobile, has a really good video of how he imagines it being matched up. I’d check it out because he makes sense of it all

Halo: Reach being a game takes precedence over the novels, anything that contradicts the game didn’t happen and the books fill in the blanks.

> 2533274829152751;16:
> Halo: Reach being a game takes precedence over the novels, anything that contradicts the game didn’t happen and the books fill in the blanks.

I tend to disagree with you there, based on 343’s embracing of the expansion of the universe via books, etc; why would they go to all the above trouble to reconcile the differences?

Reach was made by Bungie and I believe that was Bungies explanation.

> 2533274829152751;18:
> Reach was made by Bungie and I believe that was Bungies explanation.

That was Bungie’s attitude, yes, but 343 takes a different approach to things - hence all the effort put into establishing the links in the timeline Nihlus posted above. And that was being done even before the game’s release, with 343 already established as the heirs to the kingdom once Bungie’s contract was up.

Don’t forget about the Radio transmissions from Reach that tells of the possible survival of Beta-Red Team who were defending the Generators when Alpha team was destroying the Covenant staging area