What if ? Poll (Yes/No)

Reach would have to be one of the best halo games. But what would it be like if they did a film based on reach. Not with Master Chief or the noble team. If they took the film back when reach very first got attacked. So basicly it goes like this. A small group of elites land on reach. Do the first attack on vasgrade (destroying all communication outpost). The unsc send in the army to investigate, not long afterwards they are confirmed missing in action. Which starts of the full invasion of reach
There’s also the united rebel front. Which at first the unsc were pointing the fingers towards them. So image the fear, terror. Being thrown into complete chaos. Not having any idea what is attacking the planet.
So would this idea work YES/NO (maybe reason why ?)