What they did wrong.
They made the req system,
took out splitscreen
Lack of customization (compared to reach and previous games)
Lack of gamemodes like infection and race
A bad campaign (It was better than h4 but was nowhere near the original trilogy)
Crappy spawn areas.
ban system?
What they did right
longevity
having a better campaign than h4
ban system?
Kinda better physics?
listening to fan requests.
Community maps
Breakout.
Did I leave anything out?
I don’t know, it’s a matter of opinions.
REQs No splitscreen and sprint would be my top 3
> 2533274923675030;3:
> REQs No splitscreen and sprint would be my top 3
Same for me, the lack of splitscreen really makes Forge useless to me because I can’t just have my friends over to play on a map I just made.
I actually like the REQ system. Most people hate it because it is the only reason to get REQs, Now if there was other options besides it people would not feel so negative to it. But since it is the only way ,thats where people are getting mad about.
It is the prevailing opinion that Halo 4 had an excellent campaign whereas Halo 5s was very disappointing.
They did a -Yoink- job with UI.
I miss to complete challenges in order to get armors.
You think they did longevity right? I’d like to see your reasoning behind that, seeing as Halo 5 has had a massive drop in population since launch. And as far as popularity goes, it’s barely in the top 10 most played Xbox One games.
Pros
-the Hydra
-the Coliseum map
-Ground pound
-Clamber
-The hit marker animation
Cons
-Everything else
Honestly though, this is probably my least favorite game in the series so far. There is so much wrong that it’s hard for me to list it all. The top of the list without getting into the fine details though are, Sprint, the REQ system, really bad campaign, fast kill times, the art style as a whole, and the horrid UI.
What they did right
-Gameplay
-Music
-Graphics
-Forge
-Smooth frame rate
-The weapons
-Return of equal starts in arena
What they did wrong
-The Req system
-The campaign
-The aiming
-Lack of game modes and gametypes
-The user interface
-Stripping down customization options
-No option to have a black undersuit with armor
-Putting way too much emphasis on Warzone
-The ranking system
-Matchmaking
-The radar in arena
-No non-forge BTB maps
-No splitscreen
-Spartan Charge
-Removal of map and gametype voting
-The art direction of various armors coughseekercough
-No fileshare
The art is a big con for me. If every level had the darker look that Master Chiefs first level had I would like the game more. Also the way 343 neglected BTB which is my favorite gametype really hurts as well. and of course the lack of split screen is terrible
> 2533274958005868;12:
> What they did right
> -Gameplay
> -Music
> -Graphics
> -Forge
> -Smooth frame rate
> -The weapons
> -Return of equal starts in arena
>
> What they did wrong
> -The Req system
> -The campaign
> -The aiming
> -Lack of game modes and gametypes
> -The user interface
> -Stripping down customization options
> -No option to have a black undersuit with armor
> -Putting way too much emphasis on Warzone
> -The ranking system
> -Matchmaking
> -The radar in arena
> -No non-forge BTB maps
> -No splitscreen
> -Spartan Charge
> -Removal of map and gametype voting
> -The art direction of various armors coughseekercough
> -No fileshare
Pretty much this^
> 2533274865057977;14:
> > 2533274958005868;12:
> > What they did right
> > -Gameplay
> > -Music
> > -Graphics
> > -Forge
> > -Smooth frame rate
> > -The weapons
> > -Return of equal starts in arena
> >
> > What they did wrong
> > -The Req system
> > -The campaign
> > -The aiming
> > -Lack of game modes and gametypes
> > -The user interface
> > -Stripping down customization options
> > -No option to have a black undersuit with armor
> > -Putting way too much emphasis on Warzone
> > -The ranking system
> > -Matchmaking
> > -The radar in arena
> > -No non-forge BTB maps
> > -No splitscreen
> > -Spartan Charge
> > -Removal of map and gametype voting
> > -The art direction of various armors coughseekercough
> > -No fileshare
>
>
> Pretty much this^
You can add the whole “LOL WE ARE GOING TO TAKE AWAY THE EMBLEM CUSTOMIZATION AWAY SO YOU WASTE LOTS OF REQ POINTS ON PACKS FULL OF PREMADE EMBLEMS THAT NO ONE WANTS, CHEERS THANKS, BYE” - 343I 2015. I miss my maw/vortex combo emblem that looked like sonic the hedgehog spin dashing 
Halo 5 needs daily/weeky challenges to earn extra req points?