ROUND 2:
> Before MW2 came out, most of the people on your friends list would be playing Halo 3.
Yes, however was there any other stiff competition when Halo 3 was released? Modern Warfare was released a week after Halo 3, however CoD wasn’t as established of a franchise, especially from a multiplayer perspective. Once it started gaining momentum, (mind you, Halo had been an online multiplayer staple since 2004, whereas CoD came around in 2007, giving Halo a head start of over three years) by the time Modern Warfare 2 was released in 2009, Halo 3 was over two years old. Casual players transitioned because it was a new type of FPS, not a two year old game. Thus creating what people in the industry like to call “competition”.
> The other day I had the most friends playing Reach at the same time in months: 3.
It’s nearly a two year old game, how many games do you still play regularly that have a life of 2+ years? For me, it’s Halo and GTA, only because I’m avid fans of both series.
> Everyone has moved on
None of us would be here, in this very forum, if this was the case.
> 343 needs to focus on the little community it has left
HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS registered users on Waypoint, MILLIONS of fans worldwide, as well as the most anticipated game of 2012. GrfballHub, XForgery, RvB, bigteambattle.net, MLG, etc. are all communities within Halo. I wouldn’t say the community’s small by any means, in fact I’d argue Halo has the largest and most expansive fanbase out of any series.
> But to answer your question in one word: “everything.”
Reach was a different approach to the Halo series, which, unfortunately, was met with immense amounts of criticism because it differed so much from traditional Halo. It wasn’t perfect by any means, but saying “everything” was wrong with the game is blind and ignorant. No offense.
> They’ve added Perks, Custom Loadouts, Killstreaks, Weapon Unlocks, Weapon Drops, Custom Skins, Instant Respawn, Drop-in/Drop-out gameplay, etc.
Yes, they have. Are the features also in CoD? Yes. Are some of these features in every other popular FPS, such as Gears of War, Medal of Honor, Counter-Strike, Battlefield, or Soldier of Fortune? Yes. That’s how the FPS genre evolves. In this case, 343i took a well-known element that’s implemented in a variety of other FPS’s, and put their own twist on it. That’s just how the FPS genre works.
> What about that screams “Halo” to you???
Let’s ask another question: what doesn’t seem “Halo” to you? Everything that’s new, that wasn’t seen in previous Halo titles? Well, if that’s the case then we would all still be playing Halo CE clones. Just because it wasn’t in Halo CE, or 2, or 3, or Reach, doesn’t mean it’s not “Halo”.
> And are we being dramatic?
Yes.
> There used to be Hundreds and Hundreds of THOUSANDS of people playing Halo 3 EVERY DAY.
Yes, when the game first came out. Halo 3 has been out for over FIVE YEARS, and it still averages roughly 20,000 daily players and is continually in the top 20 most played Xbox Live games. Reach has been out for nearly two years, and it averages roughly 70,000 daily players, as well as normally placing in the top 5 most played Xbox Live games. What’s your point? You expect the same 100,000 people to keep playing the game, five years later? Other games come out, people move on. It’s just a video game.
> Today, in a time where more people have Xbox’s and more people have Xbox Live, the maximum number of people you will see online is about 80,000.
Again, Halo 3 averages 20,000 daily players on any given day. Reach hovers around 70,000 daily players on weekdays, while maxing at roughly 100,000 players on the weekend. Regardless of the numbers, whenever I hop n Halo 3 or Reach, I never have a problem with finding matches. Thus, does the numbers truly matter?
> I think it’s about time we started rrealising that Halo is becoming a sinking ship.
After everything that’s been revealed, including 343i’s E3 demonstration, I’d say that’s a completely and totally false statement. If anything, Halo will be MORE popular once Halo 4 is released.
It is what it is. Stop worrying about the community, so worrying about numbers, just play the video games you enjoy playing.