UNSC Infinity vs. CIS Malevolence

Who would win in a battle: the United Nations Space Command Infinity (from Halo 4), or the Confederacy of Independent Systems Malevolence (from Star Wars: The Clone Wars)? Both are flagships of their respective fleets, around 5 kilometres in length, and are equipped with weapons of mass destruction such as super-heavy MAC guns and EMP ion cannons. Who do you think would be victorious if they both came out of slip/hyper-space and fought to the death?

Well it would be hard to tell as we don’t know either energy outputs or how much there shields could take of the others fire

Malevolence for sure. That EMP burst would slaughter the infinity, and the support fleet that usually accompanies it. And, any survivors from the onslaught would be hunted down by hunting parties.

I think Infinity would win with its MAC cannons. The Malevolence would EMP the life out of the Infinity, but if Infinity kept its distance, I think it could win.