I think it could’ve been far worse.
Halo 3 left the story pretty open ended, and I truly believe that 343 had the best intentions taking it in the direction they did in 4 and 5.
Halo 4 and 5 took the story and went in a pretty radical direction in my opinion at least with the surrounding narrative. I loved what they did with Chief and Cortana in 4, and see that reflected very well in Infinite, but the story’s plot and narrative just felt like filler to tell us Chief/Cortana’s story. 5’s story just kinda fell apart because of this filler. It had threads connecting Chief’s story, but they were just stretched thin with some fan favorite characters brought in to drum up hype.
I mean heck man, 5’s story picked up where Spartan Ops left off. I didn’t even finish Spartan Ops and that was the biggest pull for me in Halo 4. Episodic narrative driven storyline that continued after the events of the campaign?! Dude sign me up! Until my friends stopped playing, and I just felt no reason to run the same missions on the same maps solo repeatedly just to get a cutscene and some filler.
I get that the Reclaimer saga will not be complete, which to those who enjoyed it and wanted to see the end: I’m truly sorry, that really sucks. However it was clear by the end of Halo 5 (which I finished by watching, after I grew frustrated and bored of playing) the direction 343 was going in was going to be more convoluted and maybe even tie up Halo for good.
I don’t think that Halo Infinite ties up all the loose ends of Halo 5, in fact I think it might end up causing more issues story wise than Halo 5 would’ve led to, however I think it buys 343 more time with the story. Those loose ends it doesn’t quite tie up are most likely the case for future plot points.
Infinite was one final chance 343 had to save Halo, while it isn’t the final shape, it at least bought the franchise some time.
I agree. There’s a lot of explaining that needs to be done yet. I don’t think I need to go into detail of course, but for example one of the issues I personally criticized the new Star Wars films for was providing necessary exposition to understand the films outside of the films themselves. My comparison: 343’s Reclaimer Saga.
The expanded universe just Big Banged and and expanded so vastly and rapidly that it made the experience unnecessarily convoluted. Not even the ads had time to catch up to the plot lines, not even the podcast stories that led up to it could catch up.
I do want to know the story that led to Cortana’s collapse, why the universe is in a state of apocalypse. I want to know the whole story rather than the blips that were shown to us. I do think we’re going to get answers, but we simply didn’t get them up front all at once.
Oh I completely agree. I don’t think it’ll be in the way you suggest though. The campaign and multiplayer both have stories, it’s clear there’s a lot more going on than the game’s plot leads us to believe we’ll see. I think 343/Infinite is going to give us expanded plots in due time. The game makes it pretty clear there’s plenty of real estate to still explore.