This ain’t it. I agree that Infinite has the best core gameplay, art direction, and campaign of any of the 343i games, and it outmatches Halo 4 and 5 handily in all of those areas (IMHO). But to suggest that this game and Halo by extention are in a good place right now isn’t at all accurate.
There isn’t enough to do in Halo Infinite, and too much of what there is is broken to a lesser or greater extent. The core gameplay is very good but is plagued by major technical issues in matchmaking and customs.
The art direction is incredible, but the vast, vast majority of armors in the game are locked behind a very transparent and overzealous monetization system. That monetization goes so far as to affect the core fun factor of multiplayer progression by incentivizing players to pay to skip levels in the BP or buy challenge swaps for the challenge system, which will generate 2-5 challenges in any given week that are exceptionally un-fun and/or very poorly thought out.
The campaign is an enjoyable romp, but is also very visually monotonous and hamstrung by lack of replay value through no co-op and no mission select feature (Yes, I know these are inbound. No, that doesn’t fix the fact that the game launched without them). In addition to that, there’s no incentivizing PvE players to engage with the campaign thanks to there being no PvE challenge deck as there was in MCC- and no secondary PvE modes for these players to enjoy apart from the campaign, either.
Even elements as fundamental as the UX/UI are plagued by underwhelming design and impressively bad performance.
There are nice things that can and should be said about Infinite. It’s my favorite 343i Halo game by a hundred miles and I think it deserves to be praised for its merits. But the truth is, for every great aspect of this game, there are several caveats and drawbacks to backhand it.
As a fanbase, we need to remember that 343i is made up of real people and that many of these people do care and want to provide a great Halo experience. We should strive to keep our feedback substantive and classy, accordingly. But we shouldn’t roll over, shut up, and accept the things that are bringing this experience down. As someone who believes Infinite has the potential to become a phenomenal Halo game with some considerable revision and expansion, I think we need to keep the feedback coming. We just need to heed the Superintendent and Keep it Clean.