I’m a feew minutes in, and his first point about health is wrong. You do have health, and it does recharge slower than CoD. You don’t see it, but there is a formula which I will try to dig up that explains it. You’re health comes back a few HP per second over a 10 second span I believe… more to come.
> I’m a feew minutes in, and his first point about health is wrong. You do have health, and it does recharge slower than CoD. You don’t see it, but there is a formula which I will try to dig up that explains it. You’re health comes back a few HP per second over a 10 second span I believe… more to come.
yes but keep watching that was a flimsy point but every other point he makes his completely valid and true
> > I’m a few minutes in, and his first point about health is wrong. You do have health, and it does recharge slower than CoD. You don’t see it, but there is a formula which I will try to dig up that explains it. You’re health comes back a few HP per second over a 10 second span I believe… more to come.
>
> yes but keep watching that was a flimsy point but every other point he makes his completely valid and true
It’s all opinionated. Not to his arguments do nothing. He states at one point, “bloom makes it so you can’t just spray and pray.” EXACTLY. Then goes on to say it slows things down. Let go of the DMR for once.
His case for armor abilities said “you can use sprint to get to a fight, or you can use jetpack to get to places on a map. but what if someone else has them?”
I’m not knocking his points or opinions. Just kinda doubting that this would be someone I’d want working for 343.
I dont want Halo 4 to be anything like Halo 3. Halo 3 IMO was the worst halo game.
I want Halo 4. Not Halo 3 2.0
The thing I like about Halo is thats its new each game. It needs to stay new.
Of course id be fine as long as there is forge 
His points are in the right general direction. I’ll give him that, but he’s definitely not someone that should be working for 343i. He doesn’t really have a solid grasp on how the game mechanics affect the game and his main argument is “because I like it that way”. Which really isn’t that bad of an argument considering he likes most of the right things (like faster paced gameplay).
I just really doubt that he would understand what game mechanics make the things he likes happen. So in short, I think 343i ought to take feedback from him, but not hire him.
> > I’m a feew minutes in, and his first point about health is wrong. You do have health, and it does recharge slower than CoD. You don’t see it, but there is a formula which I will try to dig up that explains it. You’re health comes back a few HP per second over a 10 second span I believe… more to come.
>
> yes but keep watching that was a flimsy point but every other point he makes his completely valid and true
The fact he kept comparing Halo to Call of Duty when there two separate games, he hugely misunderstands the Health system and he mentioned Realism for Halo 3, Reach and CoD in the same context, all 3 of which are not.
This guy is nothing more than someone with opinions on false facts.
“Make it like Halo 3” is not valid design direction.
Sounds like he want another copy of Halo 3
Don’t think id want him working there if he cant come up with something fresh, but, still Halo.
I’d rather have a Halo: Combat Evolved feel in a game. Halo 3 killed that feel for me…
> I dont want Halo 4 to be anything like Halo 3. Halo 3 IMO was the worst halo game.
>
> I want Halo 4. Not Halo 3 2.0
>
> The thing I like about Halo is thats its new each game. It needs to stay new.
>
> Of course id be fine as long as there is forge
Anything but reach is fine by me.