The Unofficial Map Judging and Rating Thread

Hello everybody. This thread is for any Forgers who want to have their maps tested for gameplay, or rated as an overall map. As an experienced Forger myself, I enjoy playing on many different map variants and looking at their creations.

Follow the instructions below to submit a map.

Link to your map on Bungie.net:
Completion on map:
Do you want this map rated or tested?:
Overall appearance of map:
Recommended players:
Supported gametypes:
Non-supported gametypes:

<strong>*If you are having your map tested, then it will be tested with all gametypes supported and you will recieve a full report on what elements of the map could be improved.</strong>
<strong>*If you are having your map rated, then it will be rated on appearance, gametype quality, and gameplay quality. Rating is out of 5 points.</strong>
1/5 2/5 3/5 4/5 5/5
Poor Fair Good Excellent Superior
THIS IS NOT A CONTEST. THIS IS SIMPLY FOR FORGERS WHO WANT THEIR MAPS REVIEWED.

Link to your map on Bungie.net: http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/FileDetails.aspx?fid=19092481&player=GodlyPerfection

Completion on map: Finished
Do you want this map rated or tested?: Rated
Overall appearance of map: Cleanly forged with a sort of castle like feel to it
Recommended players: 4v4
Supported gametypes: Everything except Invasion, Race, and Haloball
Non-supported gametypes: Invasion, Race, and Haloball

Hell, why not. It’s always good to get it out there. :slight_smile:

Link to your map on Bungie.net: Catacombs
Completion on map: 99% Complete (1% for anything I missed/to grow on. :D)
Do you want this map rated or tested?: Both please :slight_smile:
Overall appearance of map: It’s a dungeon map based on Diablo. You can find a thread with pictures and video(of the first release version; map has been updated) here
Recommended players: 4v4, strictly a Team map.
Supported gametypes: Meant for the Team Objective, Team Slayer, and Flagstravaganza playlists. Just test Capture the Flag and Team Slayer gametypes if you will. AR & DMR starts work well. Additionally supports most other gametypes.
Non-supported gametypes: Invasion, Race, Grifball, Non-standard gametypes etc.

Bungie.net Download Link: http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/FileDetails.aspx?fid=18400277&player=Nicholas%20Cave

Completion of map: Complete
Do you want this map rated or tested?: Either please.
Overall appearance of map: Neon lit corridors and other tight spaces (inspired by TRON, TRON: Legacy and TRON: Evolution).
Recommended players: 4-10

Supported gametypes: Slayer (Slayer, Team Slayer, Classic Slayer, Elite Slayer, Bro Slayer), Oddball (Oddball, Team Oddball), King of the Hill (King of the Hill, Team King of the Hill, Crazy King, Team Crazy King), Capture the Flag (Capture the Flag, Neutral Flag, One Flag, Multi Flag, Speedflag), Assault (Assault, Neutral Bomb, One Bomb), Headhunter (Headhunter, Team Headhunter), Stockpile, Territories (Territories, Land Grab, 3 Plots), Juggernaut, Infection (Infection, Safe Havens, Alpha Zombies), Invasion (Tron: Invasion) and Insane (Halo Chess, Speedpile).

Non-supported gametypes: Race (Race, Rally), Invasion Slayer (Invasion Slayer, Spartan Inv. Skirmish, Elite Inv. Skirmish).

Thanks!

Link to your map on bungie.net: Aldomina
Completion on map: 99% complete
Overall appearance of map: Mostly open area with some hiding spots/cover for inferiority and bases inspired somewhat by The Cage
Do you want this map to be rated or tested?: Both if that’s OK. if not just tested
Recommended players: 8v8
Supported gametypes: Slayer, Capture the flag, Assault, and Hog_ball.
Non-supported gametypes: Speed pile, territories, King of the hill, Grifball, Haloball, Race, Infection, and Invasion.

Link to your map on Bungie.net: <---- Meridian ---->
Completion on map: Finished
Do you want this map rated or tested?: Rated
Overall appearance of map: Awesome use of sky box and surrounding panoramic views. Great use of water in the lower levels as active cover. More details.
Recommended players: 2-10, can support 8v8
Supported gametypes: Everything except Invasion, Race, Haloball, and Hockey
Non-supported gametypes: Invasion, Race, Hockey and Haloball

Link to your map on Bungie.net: Dynasty
Completion on map: Finished
Do you want this map rated or tested?: Rated
Overall appearance of map: Cleanly and professionally forged map with a very forerunner aesthetic theme inspired from elements from Halo 3’s Campaign.
Recommended players: 4v4
Supported gametypes: Everything except Invasion, Infection, Race, and Haloball
Non-supported gametypes: Invasion, Infection, Race, and Haloball