"The Return" from a human POV

So, I started writing a fanfic about the destruction of Kholo and I put it in community creations, but that forum is a bit of ghost town compared to this one. So I’m posting a link to it in this forum, because I have seen links to other fan creations in this section of the forum before and I live for feedback… feedback which I won’t get in the desolate backwater that is community creations.

https://forums.halowaypoint.com/yaf_postst125268_Kholo–The-Fall–A-companion-to-The-Return.aspx

I assure my fanfiction is of quality. I have a great deal of firearms experience and military knowledge, so my fic has a Nylund-like technical edge to it that I think you folks will appreciate.

Reading it right now! I’ll let you know what I think of it when Im done.

EDIT: Just got done reading it. I enjoyed it quite a bit!

Thanks. Remember it’s not over, keep checking back.

That was really good, can’t wait to read more. Theres one error I noticed, you had the UNSC Magnum fire a 10mm round, though every variant I’ve seen so far is .50 (though maybe you intended to show a different variant?)

It is a different, earlier variant not issued since the 2400’s. you’ll note it has a hammer, unlike the Magnum which is striker fired. I meant it to be the Halo equivalent of the M1911 pistol today.

NEW SECTION ADDED: https://forums.halowaypoint.com/yaf_postst125268_Kholo--The-Fall--A-companion-to-The-Return.aspx

ABANDON YOUR HOMES. ABANDON YOUR POSTS. ABANDON ALL HOPE.

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

WINTER CONTINGENCY HAS BEEN DECLARED______________

THE STORY HAS BEEN UPDATED: https://forums.halowaypoint.com/yaf_postsm1600554_Kholo--The-Fall--A-companion-to-The-Return.aspx#post1600554

updated

Anyone want more of this? Anyone?

> Anyone want more of this? Anyone?

Yes, please. Great characters and quality writing so far. Keep it up.
Also, if you want a beta-reader feel free to PM me. I love both reading and providing feedback wherever I can.

> > Anyone want more of this? Anyone?
>
> Yes, please. Great characters and quality writing so far. Keep it up.
> Also, if you want a beta-reader feel free to PM me. I love both reading and providing feedback wherever I can.

Thanks.

> > > Anyone want more of this? Anyone?
> >
> > Yes, please. Great characters and quality writing so far. Keep it up.
> > Also, if you want a beta-reader feel free to PM me. I love both reading and providing feedback wherever I can.
>
> Thanks.

I appreciate your beta reader offer but I’ve never worked with one before and don’t feel the need to at the moment. If you have feedback after the fact I’ll incorporate it if I agree with your assessment. Better to beg forgiveness than to ask permission…

Here’s a question: What do you think of my in universe com intercepts? (the posts with the verbose, technical headers)

This is it marine:

UPDATED: https://forums.halowaypoint.com/yaf_postst125268_Kholo--The-Fall--A-companion-to-The-Return.aspx

Thoughts on the update?

I just copied all of the updates to my iPhone’s Notepad, so Ill take a look when I got some free time!

I read a paragraph or so, and I gotta say, I really like your writing style!

Thanks Alpha! Hope you enjoy it.

I absolutely loved it. Your detail outclasses my own when writing and your characters are pretty well rounded. That drop scene was probably the coolest thing I’ve read in the Haloverse as of late.

I feel it went by a little quickly, but that’s just me. The distancing method, the gradual descent and detail per line was a nice, simple approach. Not saying you should redo it, but consider expanding on the details (i.e. Fin’s perception) and seeing how it looks afterward. Otherwise, great work.

One nitpick I have to make, and it’s a common one I see in writing: the confusion of the theres. “There” describes a direction, location, or prelude to a statement (“there is,” “there are”). “Their” is the possessive form.

Also, I noticed you like to use commas a lot. I too am trying to get into making the most of that grammatical marvel, but they can sometimes make a sentence read differently when sounded out. Try looking back at some sentences of dialogue and speaking them aloud just to gauge if that’s how you want it to sound to the reader. For example, when Cooper says “It’s bad soil now, Moby -Yoink!- took care of that,” I can hear his angered tone of voice as his words are delivered at a slightly faster tempo thanks to the comma.

However in other cases, when Fin was inspecting his equipment, for example, you had a few run-on sentences. No big deal, just looks better to a possible future editor. Note possible alterations.

“The helmet was something he had never seen before<mark>;</mark> it was more rounded off than a trooper helmet<mark>, and</mark> its visor, which began right above the nose, was a narrow slit bent slightly, not unlike a flaccid crescent moon turned on its side, and polarized jet black”

Just a few things to consider. But overall, nice work.