Would be Sandtrap.
It is undoubtably the best BTB battle map to date. It was the perfect map.
I remember fondly the custom games I had on this map, the epic elephant battles, and Sand Tarp (heavy weapons). The perfect vehicle map as well.
Does anyone agree with this?
Yes
Guardian…perfect map
Zanzibar/Last Resort - How Beaver Creek made it in Reach and not this map…is beyond me. Some of the greatest halo matches I’ve experienced have been on these two maps.
> Guardian…perfect map
It would nice if they brought that back too.
> Would be Sandtrap.
>
> It is undoubtably the best BTB battle map to date. It was the perfect map.
> I remember fondly the custom games I had on this map, the epic elephant battles, and Sand Tarp (heavy weapons).
>
> Does anyone agree with this?
you’ve obviously never played CE or Halo 2 if you think sand trap is the best BTB map.
bring it back so many good memory’s about it.
> > Would be Sandtrap.
> >
> > It is undoubtably the best BTB battle map to date. It was the perfect map.
> > I remember fondly the custom games I had on this map, the epic elephant battles, and Sand Tarp (heavy weapons).
> >
> > Does anyone agree with this?
>
> you’ve obviously never played CE or Halo 2 if you think sand trap is the best BTB map.
Everyone is entitled to an Opinion, and yes I have played Halo CE and Halo 2. If you were to ask me favorite BTB maps for them, it would be: Blood Gulch in Halo CE and Headlong in Halo 2.
I hated Sandtrap, it’s way too popular just because there are Elephants. >_>
Sidewinder, Waterworks, Headlong and Breakpoint (ok not for BTB, but for 6v6 and Invasion) are my favourite ones.
> bring it back so many good memory’s about it.
If only…
It should be Midship, so we know that we at least have one good arena styled map.
while i agree that sand trap was absolutely amazing, and disagree with someone who said that the only reason it was good was elephants (that just confirmed its dominant rule of awesomeness) i do not think they should bring it back. I really think that they shouldn’t do any remakes at all.
Coag was better than blood gulch.
Guardian 
Maps from previous games won’t play the same, they might even play worse, because of new mechanics.
343 should avoid remakes.
> Coag was better than blood gulch.
Agreed.
> > Would be Sandtrap.
> >
> > It is undoubtably the best BTB battle map to date. It was the perfect map.
> > I remember fondly the custom games I had on this map, the epic elephant battles, and Sand Tarp (heavy weapons).
> >
> > Does anyone agree with this?
>
> you’ve obviously never played CE or Halo 2 if you think sand trap is the best BTB map.
Sandtrap is better than most of the CE BTB maps. Possible exceptions are Blood Gulch and Ice Fields.
As for Halo 2, I do not know what to say. I haven’t played the multiplayer very much.
I’m getting sick of the logic of “anything that is older is better.”
> Zanzibar/Last Resort - How Beaver Creek made it in Reach and not this map…is beyond me. Some of the greatest halo matches I’ve experienced have been on these two maps.
It wasn’t remade because it’s still possible to play it online via Halo 3. Plus, they usually don’t remake maps that were from the last game.
Only exception to this is Blood Gulch-Coagulation in Halo 2. But even that was not a complete remake. There were differences.
Blood Gulch is basically Halo’s signature multiplayer map. However, it would need some redoing for the new game. If they make an official Blood Gulch remake map, sweet.
I would like whatever Forge World they have (if they have it) to have an area that has the same characteristics. Blood Gulch has the perfect BTB formula.
sandtrap was good. i liked vahalla a lot better though. so much choas on that hill in the middle i loved it.