Which halo game had the best story and the best MM. Vote for yours, mine would be Halo 2 for best story and halo 4 for best MM as Halo reach was the only halo game i’ve played online previously.
Edit: i thought there could have been 2 questions for the poll. I was gonna do a poll for story and a poll for MM. Just post your favorites below.
Halo CE had the best story in my view and Halo 2 had the best MM experience…well Halo 3 was pretty great too…
I would say Halo 2 gives me the best memories with 1 coming in second but then it’s Halo 4 all the way.
Id say halo 4 however the multiplayer seems a little to dmr centered currently. I took a phantom out with it in spartan ops.
I played all Halos and read every book and Halo 4 is just amazing 
i love it myself and it is my game of the year 
halo 4. Beats 3 in variety… not sure about 2, but the campaign is better than both CE.
Halo 2 is still the best game in the franchise, then Halo 3 and the Halo CE, then Reach and Odst,would have to say Halo 4 is my least favorite along with Halo Wars.
Halo 2 had the best Campaign and Halo 3 had the best Multiplayer.
Halo 4 is. I’m still a halo wars person, avatar.
Halo 4 has the best campaign and story! No other halo games have given me this reaction when things happened. A lot of times I had my mouth wide open sometimes looking in shock, horror or awe.
Yes. I bought LE and Console.
It can be… if they fix the damn Custom Games.
Halo CE was definitely the best story. And for multiplayer my vote is Halo 2, there just hasn’t been a Halo since that nailed MM quite like Halo 2 did.
There wasn’t really any big character development in halo CE I’d say…
In halo 4, you can tell a lot by the way the characters move, their intonation and the way they talk. Of course, if you’re not paying attention to the details put into this game and all, then you’re likely going to appreciate it less.
It’s hard to say this early on. Each game also has the task of combating nostalgia which is generally a far stronger force than rationality.
At the very least, I know that this is a great Halo game. I love it. However, Halo 2 is just such a hard game to beat. The matchmaking was great, most of the maps were amazing, and I had the time of my (teenage) life playing endless numbers of custom games. Halo 4 is the first time since 2 that I’ve really enjoyed the matchmaking, however I think there’s little chance that I’ll play many custom games. To start, I hear that there are quite a few problems with custom game types. There’s also the issue that I simply don’t have as many friends (both real-world and on XBL) who play Halo as I did back in the Halo 2 days.
Campaign-wise, this was a really strong entry. It’s the most complete story since 1 (2 and 3 are really two halves of the same story, ODST was fun but didn’t have a compelling story, and Reach never really resonated with me), and it has the most depth since 2. The levels were all really fun too. My biggest disappointment was the musical score - some tracks were fantastic, but I found that, for the most part, the music served as more of a background music, complementing what was happening rather than adding to it as Bungie’s Marty did in Halo 1 through ODST (another complaint I have about Reach…didn’t much care for the music).
Campaign: Halo 4
Multiplayer: Halo 3
(Got into Halo at 3)