I was talking in the discord forums and there seemed to be a massive misunderstanding of what made the original Halo games great: Sci-fi.
Halo is packed full of Sci-fi related things… things that are close to “science” but still in the realms of entertainment and imagination. The kind of stuff books talked about before common things like satellite orbits were common knowledge and used in the real world.
From the interactions I had on the Halo discord, people confuse Sci-fi with lore, which is a whole different topic entirely. New species? Key Halo history plot points? That kind of stuff is all lore.
Science fiction is using existing science and adding to it in creative ways that bring cohesion to a fictional universe: Halo, for example, was not a reference to the “Halo Rings” we find John 117 exploring, but in fact a “Halo drop”; “high altitude low opening”: Spartans are famous for being able to fall great distances without taking injury and that fictional technological aspect comes from the real world technology of high altitude low opening research.
This is just one of the many “sci-fi” aspects of the Halo Universe that made the originals such a hit and is what is lacking in Halo Infinite (in my opinion).
Examples of topics we could explore in this thread:
How did Cortana suspend data in what seems to be thin air (matter)?
In the campaign we “pass though” memories Cortana left behind after her deletion, but people (and 117) didn’t even question how that kind of data imprinting was being done without a signal or power source: it was just “ghost data”, but the “sci-fi” technology aspect of how that “ghost data” came to be, could be an interesting topic to explore.
Feel free to add your own Sci-fi topics (with sources to real technology) and try not to get it confused with lore topics, which would cover things like “the forerunners” or “what species a grunt is”.