Small - Medium sized maps; These maps could be forged by the community and added in to MM by 343i:
Battle Creek
Sanctuary
Lockout
Midship
The Pit
Guardian
Countdown
Large maps; Since these maps are so big and involve complex moving parts these would have to be remade by 343i:
Blood Gulch
Zanzibar
Terminal
Headlong
Valhalla
Do you agree with my selection? If not, what would you change?
Every Halo 2 map that hasn’t been remade yet, especially Terminal and Waterworks. Headlong too, if you don’t count Breakneck.
what about sandtrap, personaly my favourite halo map
They should only remake maps that haven’t been remade before, like Valhalla. I can guarantee that we won’t see any of the Reach or Anniversary maps in Halo 4.
How dare you forget Sandtrap?!
Mine would be:
Sandtrap, Valhalla, [Waterworks], Guardian, Sidewinder, and Zanzibar/Last Resort in this order.
[EDIT]
I personally hope we wont see any maps that have been remade before AND that we wont see any maps seen in Halo 3 or Reach. If they’re going to bring any back, I hope they’re older ones that we haven’t seen in a while. The newest maps I would want remade are the Vista maps.
The only map that i personally believe deserves a remake is The Pit, from what i remember that was the most popular Halo 3 map i believe.
Anyhoo my wishlist is as follows, in no particular order:
-The Pit
-Guardian
-Construct
-Narrows
But in all honesty i would love to see 343i create some amazing fresh maps (mainly symmetrical).
Edit: Midship was great but the Heretic remake i hated with a passion.
Maybe have remakes as DLC, but we see where Bungie went remake crazy with Reach and not only did these remakes not justify the true version, but it took away original map possibilities.
So if the remakes are DLC here’s my wishlist:
The Pit
Lockout(why not try again)
Midship
Narrows
Construct
These are the most balanced and fun to play maps in my opinion.
Waterworks
Headlong
Zanzibar
Turf
Colossus
Containment
Relic
Terminal
Sanctuary
Make sure all fan favorite maps to be shipped on disc please.
Why not just every Halo map ever?
I say no map remakes, I want to see unique maps, not remade ones
Ω
If 343i do remake any maps (presumably for Halo 4) then my only suggestions would be Zanzibar, Valhalla and Sandtrap, my personal favourite three maps of all time.
What I would like 343i to do however, is not only remake and polish the maps, but also give each remake a unique weather effect.
For example, Sandtrap, at night. That would be so awesome.
Or how about Zanzibar after some flooding from the beach? Or a Valhalla being hammered by torrential rain?
Remakes are just that, remakes. But I will have nothing against any environmental adjustments for the sake of originality.
If i were to pic a few of my favorite maps from each game i’d like to see remade…
Halo:CE - … I think they’ve all been remade at this point… except for the one with all the damn teleporters (FOR GOOD REASON!) and Boarding action.
Halo 2 - Terminal
Relic
Waterworks
Turf
Halo 3 - Valhalla
Sandtrap
Highground
The Pit
Reach - Reach wasn’t exactly the high point in mp maps…
> Why not just every Halo map ever?
I don’t think there is place on 3 discs for that many maps, plus it will b e way to crowded. I would really hate it. I think 15 maps is enough to start off.
-How dare you forget Sandtrap?!
I didn’t forget about Sandtrap. I just don’t like that map. It’d be good for bringing back the Elephant, or a vehicle that resembles it though.
-I personally hope we wont see any maps that have been remade before AND that we wont see any maps seen in Halo 3 or Reach.
The reason why they’ve been remade is because they were and are still good, popular maps. It’s a shame you wouldn’t want to see any H3 maps because I’d rank The Pit as my all time favourite.
-So if the remakes are DLC here’s my wishlist:
The Pit
Lockout(why not try again)
Midship
Narrows
Construct
-Anyhoo my wishlist is as follows, in no particular order:
-The Pit
-Guardian
-Construct
-Narrows
I notice both of you have included Construct which is a H3 map. In my list I’ve included Countdown from Halo Reach which is very close your choice. Some may call it a spiritual successor and I think it’s fitting of that title because I feel it’s a better, more balanced map.
-What I would like 343i to do however, is not only remake and polish the maps, but also give each remake a unique weather effect.
This could be a good idea. When Bungie remade Lockout into Blackout for H3 it had a very different feel to it because of the night sky.
I agree with elik0956, no map remakes. I was quite dissapointed with all the remakes in Reach. They often don’t do justice to the original. Besides I expect game designers to be creative and surprise me.
If you twist my arm, I’d say: Zanzibar. Best Halo map ever!
> -How dare you forget Sandtrap?!
> I didn’t forget about Sandtrap. I just don’t like that map. It’d be good for bringing back the Elephant, or a vehicle that resembles it though.
Fair enough, but I think most of the community wants it back.
> If 343i do remake any maps (presumably for Halo 4) then my only suggestions would be Zanzibar, Valhalla and Sandtrap, my personal favourite three maps of all time.
>
> What I would like 343i to do however, is not only remake and polish the maps, but also give each remake a unique weather effect.
>
> For example, Sandtrap, at night. That would be so awesome.
>
> Or how about Zanzibar after some flooding from the beach? Or a Valhalla being hammered by torrential rain?
>
> Remakes are just that, remakes. But I will have nothing against any environmental adjustments for the sake of originality.
THIISISSSS
I think they should only have 2 of the following remakes on the disc.
Small/Medium:
Lockout (again)
Construct
Boarding Action
Prisoner (again)
Colossus
Midship (again)
Large:
Terminal
Waterworks
Containment
Headlong (again)
Valhalla
Sidewinder (again)
If I had to choose 2 I would take Waterworks and Construct.