Reach is not good.

Its is its number 4 ( last time I checked ) in the top most played games on XBL. A one year old game is still beating it.The Tu did not help it at all. And we have just entered Q4 of the year and Reach’s Population has barley reach 500,000 a day and big games are coming out like Skrim, MW3,etc. And I know most of you guys don’t care about population but still its getting harder to find games.

My theory is HCA is not going to help at all. The population will continue to drop until it is to 100,000 players a day. This game will suffer heavy loss until Halo 4.Battle Field 3 and Batman Arkham City are awesome and will take me away from this game ( finally ). I’ll come back but Reach is the most hated Halo game. I still love it but at times it feels like I’m playing the same thing every game.

you are playing the same thing every game, same for other games.

sadly you are right, other and better games are now out but CoD can stay at the top and hold a good population just so i don’t have to worry about screaming kids as much in other better games.

Why is fourth so bad? Halo doesn’t have to be popular for us to play it.

people that think numbers mean anything have never played mw2. you think reach is casual? think again.

> people that think numbers mean anything have never played mw2. you think reach is casual? think again.

Can’t wait to the the casual pop. disappear when MW3 comes out.

Reach the most hated game? as far as I remember it was Halo 2 actually…

The TU was not supposed to help the population, it was supposed to fix things that were truthfully imbalanced (like Armor Lock). More on topic, fourth out of about two thousand is still a helluva good placement. I don’t see why it’s so bad that Halo went down three places after being at the top for three years. While Halo still is a blockbuster series, it’s safe to say that it’s been superseded by Call of Duty. While it was certainly controversial, demographic evidence will show that competition - not Halo’s suddenly unpopular reception - is why it’s in fourth place.

There are over 800 xbox live titles. And you think that 4th is bad? Personally if I was 4th overall i’d be pretty damn happy

> Personally if I was 4th overall i’d be pretty damn happy

Congratulations, you are now Halo Reach.

COD’s appeal to casuals does not compare to Halo’s innovations. Justin “Tool” Beiber had number one hits. Does that make him the all time MASTER of music?

Well that is how the market works. You make other games to have other people come and play that game. Reach is going to die out someday. And with all the new games out, it is basically taking other people away from reach. Its going to happen. It is happening. But that is how the market works. People want new, and reach is just getting old. Most people think it has been a year, but in technology time it has been like 5 years. Games are getting better then what bungie came up with. So by the time halo 4 is out, reach will be gone.

I would like to make a “Hated” multimillion dollar earning game that after a year remains in the top 5 on xbox live and retains a 100,000 people that play it a day despite an ever increasing list of great games that it has to compete with.But Ive always been an underachiever.

Reach was the game that got me into Halo. I’d say it’s pretty good.

For the record, I’ve now played CE, H2, and H3. So no hatin’ :slight_smile:

> > people that think numbers mean anything have never played mw2. you think reach is casual? think again.
>
> Can’t wait to the the casual pop. disappear when MW3 comes out.

Doubt it… it didn’t even drop when black ops came out.

> > > people that think numbers mean anything have never played mw2. you think reach is casual? think again.
> >
> > Can’t wait to the the casual pop. disappear when MW3 comes out.
>
> Doubt it… it didn’t even drop when black ops came out.

0.o

> Reach the most hated game? as far as I remember it was Halo 2 actually…

Really? I could’ve sworn the most hated Halo was whichever was the last one released.

Reality check:

According to you if numbers mean anything wii fit is better then every halo game, same with all the cods.

Also games that are coming out this holiday season are awesome, its only natural for hardcore gamers to expand their game collection.

Also if you were alive when it came out Halo 2 was by far the most hated Halo. (even thought its a great game and haterz gonna hate)

I’m going to buy Oblivion, then buy Skyrim next month.

I think Reach is a good game, just not near as good as previous Halo installments.

Who cares? Numbers fluctuate. Loads of people still play Reach everyday. Best doesn’t equate to currently most popular.

By that logic, Lady Gaga is better than Mozart.

> Reach the most hated game? as far as I remember it was Halo 2 actually…

Lol, no.