This has been really annoying me lately. It seems if you sign into your xbox live account on Reach, the game will automatically put you on probation despite not having it the day before. I first had it when I got another few months of gold on this account after it being inactive for a year. Strangely, when I went to matchmaking it threatenned to ban my account if I quit again, even though the account hasn’t been online in a year.
It’s not just my account either, my friend hardly ever plays reach and it happened to him as well on a different xbox. Has anyone else noticed this?