Who is the better Spartan. I say Master Chief at the end of the day but I also believe it was stated that Noble 6 is the only Spartan on the same level as John because of his reputation. That and when he was the last Spartan on Reach, he left a huge piles of dead Covenant bodies and destroyed Covenant vehicles before he died.
[deleted]
They’re actually evenly matched. While Master Chief might win because he’s more battle hardened than the much younger Noble Six, but Noble Six is hyper lethal just like John, it would really just come down to luck to be honest with you.
> 2533274861713927;3:
> They’re actually evenly matched. While Master Chief might win because he’s more battle hardened than the much younger Noble Six, but Noble Six is hyper lethal just like John, it would really just come down to luck to be honest with you.
You make a good point. I mainly give the edge to the Chief cause I believe Spartan IIs are slightly stronger than Spartan IIIs. It probably would come down to who’s more lucky.
> 2535430834886694;5:
> > 2533274861713927;3:
> > They’re actually evenly matched. While Master Chief might win because he’s more battle hardened than the much younger Noble Six, but Noble Six is hyper lethal just like John, it would really just come down to luck to be honest with you.
>
>
> You make a good point. I mainly give the edge to the Chief cause I believe Spartan IIs are slightly stronger than Spartan IIIs. It probably would come down to who’s more lucky.
Yeah, it’s never really been said who was stronger to my knowledge, but I would think maybe a SPARTAN-II would be just because they would have more experience and better control over their augmentations, but I don’t really know.
[deleted]
> 2533274924007631;7:
> > 2535430834886694;4:
> > > 2533274924007631;2:
> > > Do you realize what you’ve done?
> >
> >
> > ROFL! Yes I have realized.
>
>
> Oh… Well in that case.
>
> Inb4 Halo Mythos retcons every little detail regarding the Spartan III’s.
>
> On paper, Noble Six actually has the advantage.
>
> Noble Six:
> - is a “CAT II”.
> - Received tougher training than Chief(Page 67 of Ghost of Onyx). Also learned from a Spartan II and the Spartan II’s trainer.
> - Learned from the Spartan II’s combat experience(Page 139 of Ghosts of Onyx).
> - Received augmentations that are essentially safer and more advanced(just as effective yet administered differently) versions of what the Spartan II’s received(Page 63 of Ghosts of Onyx).
> - had his combat history practically erased by ONI.
>
> Personally, these are just a few reasons for why i think Six would probably take it.
Wait this dude had rougher training than John? Oh man that has to be intense and John got it bad. And he learned from a Spartan II and the guy who trained Spartan IIs? I never knew. I swear I actually gotta start reading Halo Books and comics and all that. I always did love the lore and always read the Terminals.
> 2535430834886694;5:
> > 2533274861713927;3:
> > They’re actually evenly matched. While Master Chief might win because he’s more battle hardened than the much younger Noble Six, but Noble Six is hyper lethal just like John, it would really just come down to luck to be honest with you.
>
>
> You make a good point. I mainly give the edge to the Chief cause I believe Spartan IIs are slightly stronger than Spartan IIIs. It probably would come down to who’s more lucky.
I’d say both are equal as the original legends and badasses excuse my language please.
Master Chief!
hmmm…
Who would win?
Someone make an EPIC RAP BATTLE OF HISTORY BUT IN THE FUTURE about this!
OMG, do you realise what you have started?!? this would be a tough call. I think Noble 6 would win vs the now chief. When chief was in his prime I guess chief would win… this is so mindconfusing!
> 2535430834886694;8:
> > 2533274924007631;7:
> > > 2535430834886694;4:
> > > > 2533274924007631;2:
> > > > Do you realize what you’ve done?
> > >
> > >
> > > ROFL! Yes I have realized.
> >
> >
> > Oh… Well in that case.
> >
> > Inb4 Halo Mythos retcons every little detail regarding the Spartan III’s.
> >
> > On paper, Noble Six actually has the advantage.
> >
> > Noble Six:
> > - is a “CAT II”.
> > - Received tougher training than Chief(Page 67 of Ghost of Onyx). Also learned from a Spartan II and the Spartan II’s trainer.
> > - Learned from the Spartan II’s combat experience(Page 139 of Ghosts of Onyx).
> > - Received augmentations that are essentially safer and more advanced(just as effective yet administered differently) versions of what the Spartan II’s received(Page 63 of Ghosts of Onyx).
> > - had his combat history practically erased by ONI.
> >
> > Personally, these are just a few reasons for why i think Six would probably take it.
>
>
> Wait this dude had rougher training than John? Oh man that has to be intense and John got it bad. And he learned from a Spartan II and the guy who trained Spartan IIs? I never knew. I swear I actually gotta start reading Halo Books and comics and all that. I always did love the lore and always read the Terminals.
Yes, the S-III’s training was continually being improved by Kurt-051 and Mendez. In addition to the S-III’s going through improved S-II training they also studied the S-II’s combat operations and how they fought. On paper at least B312 should have the upper hand here but MC has some stupidly good luck so who knows.
Probably not quite what you asked for, but I can see a slight edge to Noble 6 due to the fact that he is essentially you. It’s the closest we’ve got to having a custom character for campaign and, being an Rpg fan, really enjoyed that element.
That said, The Chief is a Spartan II - which is a big advantage.
Even though I really don’t like the 3s this might be a tie, but it all depends on what Chief it is.
[deleted]
> 2533274924007631;16:
> > 2533274814165873;14:
> > Probably not quite what you asked for, but I can see a slight edge to Noble 6 due to the fact that he is essentially you. It’s the closest we’ve got to having a custom character for campaign and, being an Rpg fan, really enjoyed that element.
> >
> > That said, The Chief is a Spartan II - which is a big advantage.
>
>
> Actually, Chief being a Spartan II puts him at a disadvantage. When compared to a Cat II Spartan III that is.
Not gonna argue with you bud, don’t know enough about it and not gonna pretend I do.
At the risk of invoking a ten page essay 
- I thought the II’s were kinda accepted as the strongest of the different variants?
[deleted]
> 2533274924007631;18:
> > 2533274814165873;17:
> > > 2533274924007631;16:
> > > > 2533274814165873;14:
> > > > Probably not quite what you asked for, but I can see a slight edge to Noble 6 due to the fact that he is essentially you. It’s the closest we’ve got to having a custom character for campaign and, being an Rpg fan, really enjoyed that element.
> > > >
> > > > That said, The Chief is a Spartan II - which is a big advantage.
> > >
> > >
> > > Actually, Chief being a Spartan II puts him at a disadvantage. When compared to a Cat II Spartan III that is.
> >
> >
> > Not gonna argue with you bud, don’t know enough about it and not gonna pretend I do.
> > At the risk of invoking a ten page essay - I thought the II’s were kinda accepted as the strongest of the different variants?
>
>
> The “strongest” is a vague term. I’m assuming you mean “the best” by that? And if so, then that’s entirely up to you and not the opinion of a fan base with an obsession over Spartan II’s. I told you that a Cat II Spartan III has the advantage. Not every Spartan III.
>
> That said, I’m not going make a giant essay(who has time for that?). I’m just going to re-bullet the sources.
>
> Cat II Spartan III:
> - is a “CAT II”.
> - Received tougher training than Chief(Page 67 of Ghost of Onyx). Also learned from a Spartan II and the Spartan II’s trainer.
> - Learned from the Spartan II’s combat experience(Page 139 of Ghosts of Onyx).
> - Received augmentations that are essentially safer and more advanced(just as effective yet administered differently) versions of what the Spartan II’s received(Page 63 of Ghosts of Onyx).
>
> On paper, at least, this is why any Cat 2 Spartan III already has an advantage.
This.
Although I’d have to say, the only advantage Spartan IIs have over Spartan IIIs in the modern universe is genetics, and those can only take you so far. Personally, I’d say if a Spartan II and Spartan III are given the same equipment and are of the same age, the IIIs come out on top.
Both are practically even