PLEASE AVOID POSTING IN THIS THREAD AND USE THIS ONE. I used this thread to more so gather information to bracket the maps in a proper seeding form. If you go to that other post please vote on which maps you would like to see remade. Remember that it’s probably better to vote for maps that have yet to be remade as they are more likely to receive a remake than other maps that have gotten a remake. Don’t let that sway your opinion though…
Ok first off if you think we don’t need maps remade just don’t post. You have the right to not want any remakes. Now let’s help 343 decide on which maps deserve to be remade. I’m gonna go off the first 3 games of the trilogy. Pick a big map and a small map from each game. I will update the OP with votes as much as I possibly can. Or you can just vote for a few maps every once and a while and as long as you aren’t completely spamming a vote I’ll count it.
NOTE* you may consider some of these maps to be smaller or bigger than the category that they are in. I’m just going by whether maps were better played in BTB or Team Slayer.
Halo Combat Evolved Maps
Small
5)Battle Creek
0)Damnation
4)Rat Race
2)Prisoner
1)Chiron TL-34
4)Hang 'Em High
1)Chill Out
4)Wizard
1)Longest
1)Derelict
Large
17)Sidewinder
9)Boarding Action
4)Blood Gulch
5)Death Island
4)Danger Canyon
1)Infinity
3)Timberland
3)Ice Fields
4)Gephyrophobia
Halo 2 Maps
Small
1)Ascension
2)Colossus
3)Beaver Creek
2)Burial Mounds
1)Foundation
0)Ivory Tower
13)Lockout
9)Midship
1)Backwash
0)Elongation
1)Gemini
2)Sanctuary
9)Turf
2)Warlock
0)Desolation
0)Tombstone
Large
3)Coagulation
7)Headlong
5)Waterworks
16)Zanzibar
12)Containment
5)Relic
11)Terminal
1)Uplift
1)District
Halo 3 Maps
Small
0)Assembly
3)Blackout
0)Citadel
21)The Pit
0)Cold Storage
4)Construct
0)Epitaph
0)Foundry
5)Ghost Town
2)Narrows
0)Orbital
29)Guardian
1)Heretic
2)Isolation
Unfortunately, knowing which maps will work best as remakes is impossible until we have a feel for how Halo 4 will play out. Reach is a perfect example of old, beloved maps not working out due to gameplay and mechanic changes.
I’d like to see a Wizard remake though. Midship, Guardian and The Pit wouldn’t go amiss either.
in halo 4 i want completely new maps, i dont want any remade maps because its a NEW trilogy, so i dont know why you want remade maps, halo 4 isnt an anniversary, its a new game
Large
Boarding Action
Death Island
Danger Canyon
Infinity
Ice Fields
Gephyrophobia
Halo 2 Maps
Large
Uplift
They’re the only maps I would be happy to see remade. I don’t think they should do any that are already on 360. No Halo 3 or Reach maps. No maps that were in the CEA map pack. Focus mostly on new ones but maybe bring back a couple like boarding action that haven’t been seen in a while.
Thank you all for your votes I will update and keep this as clean as possible. I really think this will help 343 out when it comes to them deciding on which maps should be remade.
> in halo 4 i want completely new maps, i dont want any remade maps because its a NEW trilogy, so i dont know why you want remade maps, halo 4 isnt an anniversary, its a new game
It’s a “new trilogy” simply because it wasn’t planned when the first trilogy was thought up. You still follow the MC. Sure they’ll bring in new stuff i.e. Forerunner stuff, but I doubt it’s going to be much different from the way the first three halos played.
