Reading comments here, on Reddit, Gamespot, Neogaf, and much of the general internet gaming sphere, there’s a very noticeable contingent of people who:
Say MCC is ok because it works for them
Say MCC is ok because they don’t play multiplayer
Say MCC has some bugs, but works well for the most part
Say 343 Industries deserve nothing but love just for merely making the game and selling it at a reasonable price
Blame Microsoft entirely for screwing 343 Industries over with changed party architecture
Bulls*** all.
These are the facts:
MCC’s multiplayer didn’t work correctly at launch, and doesn’t work correctly now. Frank O’Connor has stated that the problems are inconsistent (and that those who are angry have every RIGHT to be negative), so SOME people may not see them. But MANY do. And keep in mind that Halo 2 and Halo 3 both had near perfect online functionality when they originally launched.
They said that the launch problems caught them totally by surprise. Maybe some, but there were just too many for ALL of them to go completely unnoticed during testing. They have never admitted to intentionally releasing a defective product, which is what they did. Period.
MCC has campaign saving problems. If you haven’t been affected, you’re lucky.
Halo 1 and Halo 2 Classic are based off of their PC ports, which are inferior to the original console versions, especially Halo 1. Problems include poor hit registration, altered map geometry, falling through maps, missing shaders, altered HUDs, and aim assist bugs, among other things.
Several control schemes have incorrectly labeled mapping/mapping not in keeping with what the original games had.
Halo 3 and 4 are using older builds than their Xbox 360 counterparts.
Halo 3’s Forge is missing certain options, meaning that some classic custom gametypes such as Grifball cannot be replicated.
Armor customization in Halo 3 and 4 is more limited in MCC than it is on 360.
Dedicated servers, a heavily hyped feature prior to launch, are a rare sight.
343 Industries has terrible PR. Nothing but vague timelines, weak apologies, and vanishing acts from the top brass.
