When I started playing Halo, the BR was incredible to me. Halo was my first modern game (I grew up on BF1942 and SWBFII) and to my then-much-younger-and-naive-mind, the BR was a miracle. A gun with a scope that shoots three times at once? It’s got to be awesome. That’s why I loved it then.
Then as I grew older, I realized that burst fire is not a Halo-specific thing and in fact exists in the real world. I also realized that it essentially does nothing but possible harm, because it basically is no different than the DMR. Yes, three bullets hit the person–which is awesome and gives the possibility of a double or even triple if your opponents are lined up right–but each bullet does less damage, making the collective damage of a single “shot” (three rounds) about the same as a DMR or Carbine, or what have you. So I personally don’t really care if it’s back or not. I’ll probably use it a lot, for old times’ sake, and I’ll probably use the Carbine or DMR a lot, for practicality sake (of course, I haven’t played Halo 4 so this is subject to change once I actually get the game).
But I think the majority of the community (not just the forum community, but everyone who will get the game) likes the BR because they’re still stuck in my “it shoots three bullets it must be better” mindset, or they’re plain nostalgic and want one of Halo’s icons, which IMO (puts on flamesuit) is a pretty pathetic icon–every game nowadays not only has burst-fire weapons, but weapons you can switch between single, burst, and automatic. I’d rather see the icons of the Plasma Rifle, or Duel Wielding, or Master Chief’s real armor (I don’t dislike the new stuff, but the old stuff was…iconic. Watching the E3 demo, I didn’t feel like it was the Chief until he started talking and the camera was in the visor), or real Halo Grunts, Jackals, and the like. I’m not opposed to change, but change for change’s sake tends to upset me.
And don’t get me wrong, I’m not anti-BR, and I’m certainly not going to boycott the game because of the graphical changes–I’ll probably even wind up liking them. But the point is, you can call it what you want, but it’s change for change’s sake, and I don’t like it.