> 2546678360738636;15:
> > 2533274880615512;14:
> > > 2546678360738636;13:
> > > Also, just to be clear for those who mentioned it. The lack of true "LAN’ play isn’t something that 343 determines, that’s a Microsoft issue. The reason we can’t LAN with Xbox One’s is because of Microsoft, NOT 343
> >
> > So, are you saying that Microsoft is forbidding 343 to add LAN play? I guess since they own 343, they could do that, but I haven’t heard any such thing. Excuse me if I don’t take your word for it, but can you link me to a source for that information?
> >
> > It’s clearly not a technical limitation of the Xbox One, because there are existing games that have true offline LAN play (without internet) on the Xbox One. All Call of Duty games have it, for example, along with Gears of War 4, and Gears of War 4 is published by Microsoft. Why not Halo 6?
>
> Before I go into this, please know I’m not attacking you. This is just a subject I’m very passionate and frustrated about.
> …
> It simply can’t be done. It’s Microsoft’s way of getting what they wanted to begin with, always being connected online, they just didn’t advertise it as such.
Thanks for the detailed reply. No offense taken. You’ve obviously had much more experience testing this than I have. My information is based on what I read, and I know there is a lot of misinformation on the internet.
My family currently has 2 original Xbox consoles and 2 Xbox 360 consoles, and we use these exclusively for system link play. We never play online. I have a huge library of system link games (2 copies each), including all the Halo games for those consoles, which we play regularly. A member of my family has an Xbox One, but I have not yet purchased a second Xbox One for the exact reasons you mention. Halo MCC and Halo 5 can’t play system link, so there’s no reason to buy another console for those games. If what you say is true, there’s no point in buying another console at all. Seems like Microsoft is losing business because of a serious lack of capabilities on their current gen consoles. And they’ve created this limitation artificially, in software. So, because of this limitation, they’ve lost sales of both consoles and games from me, and obviously others too. And they wonder why Xbox One sales aren’t so great. This is very sad that we’ve lost so much with the current gen consoles.
Yes, what you described is not LAN. If I have to be online, it’s not LAN. “Everyone under the same roof” means nothing. LAN is OFFLINE! LAN does not require the internet. LAN doesn’t require everyone to have an Xbox Live Gold membership. People don’t seem to understand that important fact.
I totally understand your frustration. I am very frustrated about this too.
P.S. I do have one question: I know I can play single player games using my Xbox Live non-Gold gamer tag offline. So, couldn’t I connect 2 Xbox Ones offline using different Xbox Live non-Gold gamer tags?