Hi everyone.
I thought there may be a sticky post already made for bugs and feedback but I can’t seem to find it so I am making one here(I found the Design Feedback sticky thread, but this is not so much about design rather issues I have found whilst playing). If there is one - please let me know and I will remove this thread and add my feedback there :). Where I find any bugs - I will try to give a ‘steps to recreate’ if at all possible, and a proposed fix, but, normally in games that is a hard to recreate scenario so it may not always be possible to give that level of detail. I would like to invite all others to use this as a place to specifically discuss bugs which have been found. If it is used, please use the format I demonstrate below to make the feedback precise enough and useful for the devs so they have a chance of actually finding and fixing them!
The platform I am playing on is Xbox One.
Bugs
Single Player:
-
Mission 3 at the start I get messages that I have failed each and every optional objective, but the game has only just begun. The loop of failure notices repeats some of the objectives.
-
Steps to* recreate: Start mission 3. Turn off xbox, turn on xbox and within a couple of seconds the loop begins. I think this is what happened - it was a couple of days ago and I have not had time to repeat it.
-
Proposed fix:* don’t assess objective completion on game load – or don’t show objective failures when the mission hasn’t finished yet.Multiplayer:
-
When infantry are capturing a energy beacon on the map (not sure of their official names!) a small ‘spinning icon’ appears, but their health bar is removed.
-
Steps to recreate:*
-
1/* Turn on ‘always on’ health bars.
-
2/* Move infantry onto capture point (I move 3 units normally) - note that one of them will have the capturing icon, and health bar removed.
-
Proposed fix:* Show health bars during capture of beacon, perhaps just float the spinner icon somewhere close to the unit, or change the unit’s selected colour etc. - During longer games on winning the game itself crashes. This has happened on a 27 minute match and a 38 minute match. It crashed both times as I destroyed the last base of the enemy. The game does not show Victory, and the victory is not recorded in the stats (it’s as if the game was never played). The game slows to about 1 frame update every minute, and if the controller was rumbling at the time of the crash, it will continue to rumble. If you wait about 5 minutes, it will eventually present a Network error display - and the ui continues as normal. Could this potentially be the opponent closing the game, shutting of their Xbox etc? My network is stable, and it was not my disconnect.
-
Steps to recreate:* Play a longer multiplayer game (I had around 4 bases, 120 unit population tier 3 units, lots and lots going on at the same time) destroy the last base of an opponent and note the game slows to a halt eventually displaying a network error.
-
Proposed fix:* If this is a game crash, then please fix the cause of the crash. If this is due to an opponent disconnect, then the game should count that as a victory for the player still in the game and a loss for the opponent who left, also it should not crash the victor’s game.General feedback
-
Pathfinding can be a bit funny. For example I want to move a specific unit to a specific location on the map near some other units. The unit can dance around, move a little somewhere near my selected location but never actually arrive to exactly where I am wanting it. This is likely to be because of hit boxes , but to the gamer, they can’t see the boxes, and the desired location should fit the unit, so it is deceiving and becomes a fiddle which is a pain - needs some work. - The MOTD has not yet changed since I purchased the game, but it continues to invite me to download the free pack – which I have done. The game recognises I have done this if i follow the download path. Also the button saying DLC is available continues to flash, despite the fact that I have the DLC installed. I also have no real idea on what the DLC actually does! - General lack of statistical data. It would be nice to see some more data on my multiplayer matches. For example a form of ‘APM’ whatever that would be for Xbox one pads. Also the ability to see at the end of the game an income against units graph (similar to what Starcraft 2 shows). It may also be nice to be able to watch replays of previous matches. This may be a cursed blessing as I quite like the fact that currently, no other player can watch what I am doing to bring myself closer to victory and then copy my strategies
- Unit information - Is there a source of information on specific units. The game often shows messages about counter units etc, but other that trial and error and just amounting experience it’s hard to know exactly what counter’s what most effectively (I know the triangle → Infantry beats Air, Air beats Ground and Ground beats Infantry? In fact is that even right!?). If there was maybe a ‘unit book’ in the game menus where you could read a bit about each unit, and commander ability, and what it is best and worst at, it would be great. - Could we have a way to cycle through each base quickly (there may be a way I just am yet to find it?) Maybe double tapping down (I think that’s the shortcut?) and then repeating that would cycle to each base. - **Well done! You have built an exceptional console strategy game! By far and away the best I have ever played – well well well done! I am already a massive fan and will be here for the long run, am excited to see the game mature :)**That’s it for now - I will continue to play, and report back my findings. I hope this is helpful. It would be useful for me to know if 343 or Creative Assembly are reading and watching this thread so I know whether or not it is worthwhile reporting my findings in this form.