For the new Halo members "You picked a hell of a day to join up. " When Xbox live added Party Chat Custom game died (with a silent death for matchmaking)… It killed off the Halo 2/ Pre-Halo 3 generation. Which I like too call the social generation of players.
With no underestimation of the name social gen, we had the most fun to say the least. As far as Halo 2, partys would be active in chat, and developed the colors of custom game “Honor rules”. Games like hit-man, zombies, troy and other fun games would be impossible to develop and play with out in-game chat. It also created more friendships.
We then get to Halo 3 (the best custom game fun), were Honor rules were now at a minimum. Which made the game even more enjoyable with the lack of people complaining of people not following rules, and the atmosphere of the party would be awesome with the voices of everyone talking.
Halo 3 had fantastic communication. A team channel were you can only hear your team (zombies/other slayer variants), and the ONLY time you could hear your opponent was when they were near you! (Perfect for Zombies when you could hear the horde coming closer, and them letting you know your going to die lol)
From a multiplayer standpoint it was good as well! People who get randomly pair with you ACTUALLY TALKED! Calling out stuff in the game for intense teamwork. (again more friendships were made) and the ever so awesome “team trash talk” in post/pre game lobby.
Xbox had an update, and we got party chat… It killed everything! Multiplayer got silent, People in multiplayer who had mics would be in party chat when playing games, and in custom game you would get people in party chats who refuse to get out of there party. The only way to resolve was to boot, or be lonely lol.
Then Reach just killed it when you could bluntly hear the other team talking in a zombies match. Don’t get me wrong people still talk, but its not like before, and getting people out of there partys is just a hassle… Also, stuff like this do still happen, but rarely …
Finally my Proposal
Remove the hear everone in Flood mode/ and in other game variants. Make it so only humans can hear humans, and flood only hear flood, team only team. the only time they can hear each other is if they were in close proximity.
Have an option in custom game to prevent party chat, and have a wargames playlist (like call of duty S&D) and have the in game chat only to start.
