As far as Halo’s story is concerned, Halo CE to Halo 3 pretty much told the story of the Human Covenant war. There wasn’t much to add. Reach and Halo Wars expanded upon that idea, but really it was going to be difficult.
Halo 4 actually had a pretty good story in my opinion. Landing on Requiem for the first time is comparable to landing on the Halo Ring in CE. Exploring the story of Master Chief, making him more human… it worked in my personal opinion. The Bungie games, whilst they did have reasons, never really touched on Chiefs character. Despite being the savior of Humanity… he wasn’t seen as being Human in a strange way.
Halo 5 then ruined Halo 4’s ending and tried rebooting the story. The result? Well… we all know Halo 5’s story failed. False advertising, a forgettable story, and worst of all it took away from previous Halo titles. That, is the worst possible outcome.
And then Infinite, which basically rebooted the story of Halo 5… Starting to see a patern here.
Zeta Halo was lifeless with the same biome stretching throughout the entire map. Again, we were lied to with large wildlife being seen in trailers and different biomes being seen in concept art. Cortana, who died in 4, came back in 5 and turned evil, now dies off screen due to Atriox, a character who we’re also led to believe dies off screen… Great writing 343i.
Ultimately, the story of Halo has become so muddled at this point that it makes me, and likely quite a few other fans, wonder what the point is?
It’s similar to Red Vs Blue from Rooster Teeth. They had the perfect ending, but decided to continue anyway because Money. There were certainly stories that could’ve been really awesome to see, and different characters fans would’ve liked to follow. Take Red Team from Halo Wars. 343i could’ve had Jerome become the main character, and it would’ve made a lot more sense. He was created by Ensemble Studios, a company which was owned by Microsoft. Using him would give 343i more identity and allow them to create a better story.
Unfortunately, it would seem they didn’t think this far ahead.