A relatively decent amount of people were disappointed by Halo 4, from what I can observe. Many people still enjoyed it, but there are still many people that wanted more from it. I can count myself as one of the people that were disappointed, but I think my expectations were too high for 343.
Only a fair way through development, did they actually have enough employees to make an impact, before that the team was pretty small. I think it’s amazing they even got the game finished. Not to mention the fact all of these people never even worked together before, in a newly formed company. And I wouldn’t be surprised if it takes even longer for everyone to get integrated with each other.
To make matters worse, they inherited a long running AAA franchise which a majority of them never worked on before, on an almost decade old piece of hardware with only 500mb of ram! I could only imagine the things that had to be cut on the sole fact the hardware had such limited memory. I consider Halo 4 a learning experience for 343.
Now, they’ve already been together for over 4 years, have released 2 games, and their next game (which is most likely Halo 5) is being released on brand new hardware, with a large already established team (which has gained enough Halo game development experience). With the Xbox one, they have 8gb of DDR3 ram to play with; that’s over 16 times more than the 360. Not to mention the brand new CPU and graphics card. I think it’s safe to say: The sky is the limit now. They are no longer restricted by old hardware, and now the only limit they really have is their imagination.
The most common complaint about Halo 4 was it’s levels, they were linear and pretty small compared to previous Halo games. I think it’s obvious why they couldn’t have big or non linear levels: Because of the limitations of memory of the 360. There are many things you can’t have because of limitations in hardware, but even with the limitations, they produced pretty high fidelity graphics. 343 have a clear shot of making something amazing, and I think at this point it’s almost impossible for them to disappoint anyone with the jump in hardware. My bet is Halo 5 will be one of the best Halo games so far.