> Of course. I, and those of like mind, will definitely let go of our need for Halo 2 Anniversary; after it is released. After looking back, we can all move forward together. Delaying Halo 5 until 2015 and filling 2014 with Halo 2 Anniversary could only be good for Halo 5 and the franchise as a whole. Side games and other media that advance and enrich the plot could, of course, accompany both titles, be released in between, and in the years to follow.
I don’t see how a remake is going to enrich the plot by rehashing the same material we’ve known for the past 9 years.
> Think of it this way. Once Halo 2 Anniversary is released, it won’t be in the way, hordes of Halo 2 fans won’t be requesting it, and it won’t, contrary to popular belief, start an endless chain of remakes. It would take up minimal resources, be outsourced to another team, satisfy a large portion of the Halo community, make a hefty profit, as well as re-expose that vital part of the story to Halo players - in glorious HD.
And yet I don’t see how re-introducing this story will do anything. It has very little grasp as to what is going on now. Post-Halo 3 is all about humanity rising from the ashes of the Human-Covenant War and finding its role in the galaxy. How does Halo 2’s story relate to that theme?
> Honestly, at this point, it’s more realistic to expect Halo 2 Anniversary to happen than to expect its proponents to stop wanting it so desperately. Of course, it’s not confirmed, and it could still not happen, but it’s something that a lot of people desperately want to see and that, if it happened, would have a negligible impact on its opponents. Seriously, it wouldn’t hurt you guys at all, unless you were sad and angry that a small group of people could re-experience the joy and wonder they felt in 2004 in a whole new way. 
It isn’t about not wanting to see people be happy, it is about wanting the franchise to grow. Remakes are essentially filler and filler is rarely ever beneficial to a growing or established franchise. Cortana said it best, a lot can happen in 5 years and a lot did seem to happen.
> Microsoft is milking Halo for all it’s got right now, so you really don’t need to worry about a lack of new material. <mark>Revisiting the past to see what made Halo great (to a lot of fans, at least) is never a bad idea.</mark> Some of those people might be disappointed when Halo 2 Anniversary doesn’t include multiplayer, but I have realistic expectations. If it is released, it will most likely only include Campaign, which I’d be more than happy with.
When it doesn’t let the franchise grow and is used to make a quick buck because of a lack of creativity or initiative, I’d say it can be a bad idea.