To me the reason that Halo has been such a great franchise is its flexibility and its support of multiple styles of play. The play in Halo 4 ranged greatly from the goofy to the extremely competitive.
Halo 4 has taken the franchise in a new direction; they are removing too much of the franchise and pandering to the mediocre casual midsection of the game. True we had a step up in terms of story line and there have been some things good that we have added to the plate but the community is dwindling due to odd decision making.
The competitive crowd is largely been ignored since Reach came out. The lack of ranked playlists and competitive game settings has driven away a strong part of our community.
On the other end of the spectrum - the end I sit on - the fun has been sucked out of the game as well. The last straw for me is the removal of the mongoose from half of the BTB maps. Why? That is my tool of destruction. I cannot play Halo 4 without it I will be honest. I have amassed almost 60,000 splatters with the thing. This is not just about me though, with the gooses removal the last of the alternative killing methods is gone.
Falcon splatter/pilot community: Dead
Mongoose splatter community: Dead
Trick jumping community: Dead (the ceiling on maps is way too low)
Competitive community: Dead
Driving community: Dead (hello plasma pistol+ Nades)
Custom games community: Dead
To fix the population on Halo 4, or be successful in Halo 5 we need drastic changes.
We need the plasma pistol and sticky load outs to end. The warthog and mongoose should be on every single BTB map.
There is absolutely no reason to keep the map ceiling so low. The amazing skybox and physics of Halo have been with us since CE… Give us the ability to launch ourselves out of maps –ESPECIALY MATCHMADE MAPS – again. Put in soft kill barriers, just let us have fun.
Visible rank and competitive settings must come back or the fans who like these things will not.
Custom game types need to be re-introduced into the Halo universe. Instead of taking away large tracts of fun, bring it all back and add some new ideas of your own.
Halo 4 before the update was holding onto me by a thread. Now they have taken away from me the last thing about Halo that I truly loved. I need my mongoose back. I need my fun back. I want Halo to be Halo again.