Halo 4 - Did 343 let us down?

I would like to take this time to put some of my views out there regarding the newest addition to the Halo franchise. Words cannot simply describe the excitement I felt coming up to the release of Halo 4, as I’m sure a-lot of people would agree with me. The feeling of walking into the midnight release and picking up the copy after such a long time of waiting was bliss. I immediately rushed home and and just couldn’t wait to get back into the feet of The Master Chief. I played the first mission of the campaign and I must admit, I was blown away. However, I think that this was just my over-excitement putting my into some sort of numb state where I couldn’t actually judge if the game was good or not. This is where it all goes downhill.

I’m going to start by saying how I, and some of my friends felt. Then, I will begin the ‘oh-so’ long list of problems I find with the game.

I have been a dedicated Halo player. I have every game right from CE. It was ‘the’ game of my childhood. It made me feel like nothing else had ever before, it took you on a journey that ‘you’ were a part of. To say I didn’t get that feeling with the Halo 4 campaign, would be an understatement. The sheer feeling of utter disappointment not only with how the campaign played, but also the actual story. What I first noticed was that If you had not read the Halo books, you were completely lost. This is very poor on 343’s front. They cannot expect people to read a book on the universe of the game, when all that person wants to do is actually play it. I know I’m not the only one who was disappointed with the ending. No spoilers, don’t worry but to be honest it’s almost better having it spoiled rather than being crushed and left with an awful cliff-hanger. I have walked away from every Halo game feeling some-what ‘epic’, if that is the best word to describe it. I did not get that at all with this game. Instead of a great and powerful feeling you get from the end of Bungie’s games, all you feel from the end of Halo 4 is depression and sadness.

Here are a list of problems I, and my friends found with the campaign:

The Soundtrack - Now, I have to admit, I think that 343 have an absolutely amazing game soundtrack. However, you simply cannot compare it to the likes of the Halo 2 and Halo 3 soundtrack (The latter being my personal favorite.) One of the main problems with the soundtrack with this game is that it sounded too electric. The use of synthesizers etc. Now, maybe I’m being a little too harsh, because even through all of the flaws, I did enjoy the soundtrack. This is my biggest problem, did you ever notice that when playing the campaign you would would have to turn you TV up really loud? That’s because the soundtrack was just too quiet. It acted as back-round music when It should have been as loud as the gunfire. It completely destroys the atmosphere when the music is too soft. It needs to be loud and almost ‘in-your face’ about it, it has to take you on a journey like a wave just like how it was with previous Halo Titles.

Repetitive Game-play - The Halo 4 campaign was not an experience you would remember. The campaign was essentially running from USB port to USB port there was no challenge for the gamer as you could easily just speed run every single level. (Excluding the Broadsword mission.) Long parts of missions were also just running back and forth and shooting people on the way. To put it bluntly, the campaign was just boring.

In conclusion, the Halo 4 campaign experience was a major let down, the only the the campaign really had going for it was some of the cut-scenes and the graffix but to be honest, people play the campaign for the story not how it looks, I mean come on we’re not Call Of Duty here are we?

Oh wait, that’s exactly what has happened. When developing the game 343 had a look at what was popular, what made the most money and what attracted most fans. Take a guess what game they looked at. 343 ruined the classic Halo online multiplayer experience. There are an alarming number of ways in which 343 attempted to build a successful game by mimicking COD.

  1. Loadouts
  2. Grenade indicators
  3. Killcam
  4. Ordinance drops, comparable to kill-streaks
  5. Point system, instead of kill number
  6. Spartan Ops, comparable to Spec Ops
    These are, but to name a few of the ways in which 343 ruined Halo 4 multiplayer and If you don’t believe that they copied COD then you are just delusional. The game doesn’t even feel like Halo anymore. Halo used to be the one FPS that was different from the others. It stood out among the likes of “Battlefield”,“COD” and “Medal Of Honor”. It has now fallen into the same category as these games and is merely using the same ‘copy and paste’ formula that these games use. The multiplayer is way too fast-paced. In previous Halo titles you use to be able to have a plan and use strategy to out-wit your opponents. Now however, it is just a ‘run and gun’ game, no plan, no thought.Among all of these problems there are even more. The armor is dreadful and with all of the detail they tried putting in they made all of the armor look ridiculous and cartoon-like. I know I’m not alone when I say that I’m annoyed that there is no human aerial vehicles. The only reason they don’t have them in the game is just so that they actually have something to put into Halo 5. Basically, its like given candy to a child taking it away from them so they want it even more and then give it back to them. It is almost like 343 don’t even care about their fans. On the opening week there were constant server crashes. The file-browser still continues not to work to this day and they have basically spat on both the racing and competitive community by not having any race gametype and no ranked playlists what-so-ever. It doesn’t matter if they say that they are going to fix this because this is stuff that should have been there from day 1. Flood mode, although a wonderful idea is a complete let-down. The lunge is absolutely ridiculous and the thruster pack for Flood online is way too OP. Also, things which we could do regarding gametype editing in previous Halo titles have now been removed. Why? Because 343 just need something to give us in Halo 5 because they can’t think of anything new.

Although I enjoy the story of Spartan Ops, there is no doubt that it is not only a complete copy from the “Call Of Duty” ‘Spec Ops’ but it is a bad replacement for firefight. Spartan Ops completely lacks replay ability and is to be quite honest, boring as it offers no real challenge for the player.

The maps are awful also, its no wonder that when you go into ‘Big Team’ people always vote for Ragnarock. Its because 343 didn’t even design the map!

In conclusion, 343 have been handed a series which we all know and love and they have let us down. We put our trust in them and they let us down. They’ve taken what was once the best series of games for a console and flushed it down the toilet. Now, you’re going to have people saying that “You have to move on” and “Get with the times”. This is immature and childish. You don’t just take a franchise that people have played and loved for over 10 years and just change it because you wont your own name on it. That is exactly what 343 have done and I can say I feel nothing but disappointment and a sense of shame that we have gone so low.

H4 should have been like shooting fish in a barrel and somehow 343i missed.

I have to agree with you. At first, I thought it was a amazing game, but once I got my hands on it, I realized it just was not good. (IMO)

I don’t have much to say, because what you said sums my thoughts up.

I agree with you, op.

Brace yourselves for the defense force…

Agreed on all fronts.

This post has been edited by a moderator. Please refrain from posting bumps that do not contribute to the topic at hand.

*Original post. Click at your own discretion.

> I agree with you, op.
>
> Brace yourselves for the defense force…

I loved halo 4 and was majorly jealous when my friends ahd it, but when i got it, i wasted a good preseant on christmas for some 2.0 GB multiplayer download, short but confusing campaign, and a easy multiplayer.

But ya, i love halo 4 but now after this thread, im thinking i might have to become a COD fan unless 343i fixes these mistakes in halo 5 :?

anyway, here comes the train waggon full of haters to this thread… BRACE FOR IMPACT

I really want to hate on Halo 4, really I do. But I refuse to do it with no reasoning.

> That’s because the soundtrack was just too quiet. It acted as back-round music when It should have been as loud as the gunfire. It completely destroys the atmosphere when the music is too soft. It needs to be loud and almost ‘in-your face’ about it, it has to take you on a journey like a wave just like how it was with previous Halo Titles.

Loud music = can’t hear dialogue

Also, it actually kills the atmosphere. CE, Halo 3, and Reach had music that died out. Halo 2 and Halo 4 forces the music upon you and sometimes it can be ridiculous (playing when I’m not even fighting).

I’m glad the damn music was less louder.

I just wish there was an in-game option to turn it off or control how it plays (i.e. repeat loop, no repeat). I have to play my own music (via music library) to stop it from playing. Isn’t that just sad?

> Repetitive Game-play - The Halo 4 campaign was not an experience you would remember.
>
> The campaign was essentially running from USB port to USB port there was no challenge for the gamer as you could easily just speed run every single level. (Excluding the Broadsword mission.)
>
> Long parts of missions were also just running back and forth and shooting people on the way. To put it bluntly, the campaign was just boring.

Agreed, it’s not memorable.

FYI, Reach Campaign was like that too. Though it did have much more forced firefights. Halo 4’s firefights plays itself, with the Banshees ending up driving into walls or flying to the bottom of the map. It’s even possible to glitch past some firefights (i.e. on Composer, there’s a soft wall you can use to skip the second airlock fight).

Do you mean backtracking? Don’t the guns disappearing too quickly render that obsolete?

> In conclusion, the Halo 4 campaign experience was a major let down, the only the the campaign really had going for it was some of the cut-scenes and the graffix but to be honest, people play the campaign for the story not how it looks, I mean come on we’re not Call Of Duty here are we?
>
> Oh wait, that’s exactly what has happened. When developing the game 343 had a look at what was popular, what made the most money and what attracted most fans.

No, people play the campaign for the gameplay.

But yes, 343’s prioritization on graphics, story, and online gameplay (Spartan Ops) clearly shows the path Halo is taking (hint: modern shooter). It’s not pretty.

BRACE FOR IMPACT

kind of agree this game is not complete

Can’t speak for anyone else, and won’t speak for anyone else, but…
I’m thoroughly impressed by Halo 4. Does it have faults? Yes. But so do thousands of other games. Nothing is perfect. Perfection is a human ideal, flawed in it’s very nature. It doesn’t exist in nature, nor man-made. Everything has faults. Nothing is perfect.
From the graphics, to the story, to the characters, to the audio, music, dialogue, voice acting, and Infinity experience, Halo 4 impressed me on all counts.
If I had to score it, I would give it a 4.5/5.

> Can’t speak for anyone else, and won’t speak for anyone else, but…
>
> I’m thoroughly impressed by Halo 4. Does it have faults? Yes. But so do thousands of other games. Nothing is perfect. Perfection is a human ideal, flawed in it’s very nature. It doesn’t exist in nature, nor man-made. Everything has faults. Nothing is perfect.
>
> From the graphics, to the story, to the characters, to the audio, music, dialogue, voice acting, and Infinity experience, Halo 4 impressed me on all counts.
>
> If I had to score it, I would give it a 4.5/5.

I can see where you’re coming from. You’re right. Nothing is perfect. And it is unfair to expect a game so loved by the community to be passed to another company and made perfect. However, I do believe I said nothing to do with the game being perfect or not. I made no such statement saying that the previous Halo games were perfect, they have their flaws also. I honestly don’t know where you came up with the notion that I believe that everything is perfect concerning previous Halo titles, because I don’t. But I have to say one thing, Halo 4 is as far from perfection as any other Halo game.

> H4 should have been like shooting fish in a barrel and somehow 343i missed.

I like this quote I may use it at a later time.

Great post.

Halo 4 is an amazing game but it left a bitter-taste in my tongue with the Multiplayer Imbalance. There’s nothing wrong with the progress its making but “personally” I think the issue comes with Halo 4’s re-playability; something “isn’t” right I know it! But I can’t find it no matter how hard I try.

343 Industries’ development of “Halo 4” stomps all over everything Bungie worked so hard to create and maintain over a decade.

Yes, they let us down.

Also, I went to EB Games yesterday and saw Halo 4 in the “recycled games” pile. Lol.

> H4 should have been like shooting fish in a barrel and somehow 343i missed.

Not reading, the answer to question is yes. Good day.

> Can’t speak for anyone else, and won’t speak for anyone else, but…
> I’m thoroughly impressed by Halo 4. <mark>Does it have faults? Yes. But so do thousands of other games. Nothing is perfect.</mark> Perfection is a human ideal, flawed in it’s very nature. It doesn’t exist in nature, nor man-made. Everything has faults. Nothing is perfect.
> From the graphics, to the story, to the characters, to the audio, music, dialogue, voice acting, and Infinity experience, Halo 4 impressed me on all counts.
> If I had to score it, I would give it a 4.5/5.

NO!

slaps, grabs head and prys head towards Halo 4 box

LOOK! LOOK AT HALO 4 AND STOP COMPARING IT TO OTHER SERIES OTHER THAN IT! STOP USING THE EXCUSE THAT “OTHER GAMES ARE BAD, TOO!”

SURE “NOTHING IS PERFECT” (rolls eyes), BUT THIS ISN’T EVEN CLOSE!
IS IT A GOOD GAME OR NOT?

343 only let you down if you had completely unrealistic sky high expectations.

> NO!
>
> slaps, grabs head and turn towards Halo 4 box
>
> LOOK! LOOK AT HALO 4 AND STOP COMPARING IT TO OTHER SERIES OTHER THAN IT! STOP USING THE EXCUSE THAT “OTHER GAMES ARE BAD, TOO!”
>
> IS IT A GOOD GAME OR NOT?

Lord I dislike colored text.

To answer your question: Yes it is.

It’s the only Halo game I’ve traded in.
And the only limited edition of a game I’ve traded in.
And the only game I’ve traded in within two months of getting it.
So, yes. I can’t begin to explain.