Let’s be honest, the maps released so far have been sort of…“Meh”. Castle could change all that, but my idea is that 343 release a Classic Map Pack. 4 maps with 1 from each past Halo game.
For example;
Hang 'Em High - Halo CE
Beaver Creek - Halo 2
Sandtrap - Halo 3
Sword Base - Halo Reach
These are not my personal selections by the way.
So, if you could bring back 1 map from each of the previous 4 major Halo titles, which ones would they be?
Swordbase…
You have to be joking.
> Swordbase…
>
>
>
> You have to be joking.
Did I, or did I not say those were my personal choices?
> Did I, or did I not say those were my personal choices?
Yeah but I mean Swordbase was so bad, it should never be used as an example, except if the question was “What do you think was a really bad map?”
Halo CE: Prisoner
Halo 2: Midship
Halo 3: Cold Storage
Halo Reach: Condemned
Condemned in Reach was brilliant (and that Skybox… WOW)
He meant to say Countdown.
> He meant to say Countdown.
Funnily enough, that probably would be my personal choice for Reach.
I would love a classis map pack they is so many good maps from halo 1-3.mine would be sandtrap.
> > Did I, or did I not say those were my personal choices?
>
> Yeah but I mean Swordbase was so bad, it should never be used as an example, except if the question was “What do you think was a really bad map?”
I found this to be extremely giggle worthy. Thank you! 
lol
OP I would have to go with…
BTB Classic
CE: Sidewinder
H2: Terminal
H3: Sandbox(you can never have enough forge maps and H3 maps suck)
HR: Highlands(the only non-remake map in Reach worth ever mentioning as a good map.
Arena Classic
CE: Chill Out
H2: Lockout
H3: Guardian
HR: Zealot(considering how terrible every map in this game is and you’re making me choose.)
I’d say avoid Reach maps though altogether none of them are really worth remaking. We should just try to forget that game’s maps altogether.
Blood Gulch
Coagulation
Valhalla
Hemorrhage
I pretty much agree with Shabutie, so I’ll just edit his. (Or hers?)
> BTB Classic
>
> CE: Sidewinder
> H2: Terminal (there are really a lot of good ones here, so I’ll just stick with Shabutie)
> H3: SandTRAP
> HR: Highlands(the only non-remake map in Reach worth ever mentioning as a good map.
>
> Medium Classic
>
> CE: Hang 'me High
> H2: Zanzibar
> H3: High Ground
> HR: Anchor 9
>
> Arena Classic
>
> CE: Chill Out
> H2: Lockout
> H3: Guardian
> HR: Countdown (sorry Shabutie…)
And I pretty much agree with SloppyBottom, so I’ll just edit theirs.
> I pretty much agree with Shabutie, so I’ll just edit his. (Or hers?)
>
>
>
> > BTB Classic
> >
> > CE: Sidewinder
> > H2: Terminal OR Headlong OR Wetworks
> > H3: SandTRAP
> > HR: Highlands(the only non-remake map in Reach worth ever mentioning as a good map.
> >
> > Medium Classic
> >
> > CE: Hang 'me High
> > H2: Zanzibar
> > H3: High Ground
> > HR: Anchor 9
> >
> > Arena Classic
> >
> > CE: Chill Out
> > H2: Lockout OR Midship
> > H3: The Pit (Sorry guys, the pit’ll be more universal than guardian)
> > HR: Countdown
> I pretty much agree with Shabutie, so I’ll just edit his. (Or hers?)
>
>
>
> > BTB Classic
> >
> > CE: Sidewinder/ Deathisland
> > H2: Terminal (there are really a lot of good ones here, so I’ll just stick with Shabutie) I think waterworks was the best Halo 2 BtB Map
> > H3: SandTRAP
> > HR: Highlands(the only non-remake map in Reach worth ever mentioning as a good map. Spire and boneyard are Good too…
> >
> > Medium Classic
> >
> > CE: Hang 'me High
> > H2: Zanzibar
> > H3: High Ground
> > HR: Anchor 9
> >
> > Arena Classic
> >
> > CE: Chill Out
> > H2: Lockout
> > H3: Guardian
> > HR: Countdown (sorry Shabutie…)
This (:
> I pretty much agree with Shabutie, so I’ll just edit his. (Or hers?)
or “it’s”? 
I’m glad you mostly agree with the maps. I forgot about Countdown which is certainly better than Zealot. Reach maps just basically left no impression on me so I just kinda named the first symmetrical map that came to mind. lol
Halo CE: Hang em High
Halo 2: Turf
Halo 3: Guardian
Halo Reach: Zealot
I’ll make a list of what I’d like to see from each game…
From Halo CE:
From Halo 2:
From Halo 3:
From Halo: Reach
Halo CE: Gephyrophobia (Sadly it was only on PC great map though)
Halo 2: Zanzibar (Yes I Know it as in Halo 3 as well)
Halo 3: Sandtrap all the way!
Halo Reach: Spire
Halo CE: Wizard
Halo 2: Midship (Halo 3’s Heretic)
Halo 3: Guardian
Reach: Countdown
Arena Classic MP:
H:CE: Gephyrophobia
H2: Elongation
H3: Last Resort
HR: Countdown
BTB Classic:
H:CE: Blood Gultch
H2: Zanzibar
H3: Sandtrap
HR: Spire
Battle Creek - Halo CE
Colossus - Halo 2
The Pit - Halo 3
Arena Zealot - Halo Reach