Call me nostalgic, I don’t care. So much of what is in this video is missing from Halo 5.
The social inclusion, the competitive but friendly games, the ambition. All the little details that were made to make Halo feel alive and vibrant are just not there.
Blame 343i, blame MS, blame the community, it doesn’t matter. Just don’t pretend like supporting the drive towards “modern” gaming has resulted in a better experience.
I’ve always been a proud supporter of 343i understanding what made Halo great to begin with, to understand where Halo should go. It’s understandable they wanted to forge their own path with Halo. But taking on a loved and established franchise without apparent love or understanding of how Halo earned the love and dedication of so many millions (without the easy escape of “oh well every franchise declines, this is normal” while also conveniently removing all bits of personality from franchise to “keep it alive”) It’s just been a death sentence to that love and dedication of the franchise.
Halo 4 was built on casual play. Halo 5 was built on competitive play. The Halo franchise was built on social play, but supported all other types of play, including casual and competitive.
I argued along side many other when Halo 4 released that it was too casual and needed a competitive focus coming up for Halo 5. For whatever reason this was taken as a sign that we wanted 60fps over Split Screen, complex over simple yet deep controls, Warzone over social playlist, always online dedicated servers over LAN and so on.
But I want to stress right here, right now, that Halo needs everything.
Not as a focus but in support of its social experience. The gameplay and social experience is what we enjoyed, but the many different facets of the Halo community meant the multiple features gave us all a game that we could enjoy the way we wanted to enjoy it. The recent focus on smaller areas of the community has left huge parts of the community out to dry. As a AAA flagship title there is no reason why Halo wouldn’t have the financial and technical support from MS to bring this to life.
If gone are the days that Halo is a fun social shooter that included everybody, if gone are the days that the Halo games saw the support they and the community deserved, then gone are the days the community will stay, and gone are the days Halo brings people together.
(I wrote this really quickly because I’m starving and must eat. I know they’ll be the obligatory “why so dramatic, Halo is fine” posts, but I think it’s essential to recognise the drastic change in direction and the drastic negative effects it has had on the experience as a whole, and being in denial about it doesn’t solve the problem)