FIX THE GOSH DARN MELEE SYSTEM.

Okay, 343 really needs to fix this.

This may not make sense, but look at these clips to show evidence that they need to fix this.
https://account.xbox.com/en-us/gameclip/d2a83960-6dd1-4c76-afb0-5e79389e59ff?gamerTag=Emberburst&scid=1370999b-fca2-4c53-8ec5-73493bcb67e5
https://account.xbox.com/en-us/gameclip/0c264145-e003-4fa5-8aa0-26344ee83571?gamerTag=Emberburst&scid=1370999b-fca2-4c53-8ec5-73493bcb67e5
https://account.xbox.com/en-us/gameclip/b5025465-6d32-44e3-8593-d61d1cfa3580?gamerTag=Emberburst&scid=1370999b-fca2-4c53-8ec5-73493bcb67e5
https://account.xbox.com/en-us/gameclip/e1a2f8e3-7a60-46b5-8951-0637d262cffd?gamerTag=Emberburst&scid=1370999b-fca2-4c53-8ec5-73493bcb67e5
https://account.xbox.com/en-us/gameclip/d454e053-b5c5-4208-b013-90567d43b4f4?gamerTag=Emberburst&scid=1370999b-fca2-4c53-8ec5-73493bcb67e5

Basically, they need to fix THIS in breakout.

Again, this may not make sense, but you get the idea.

it’s not melee that’s the issue for breakout, it’s the fact that you don’t have a shield. which means one hit melees

I know that for sure, but it’s no fair that the enemy team won because of THAT. :frowning:

> 2533274817492720;2:
> it’s not melee that’s the issue for breakout, it’s the fact that you don’t have a shield. which means one hit melees

Yes but like look how they like kill each other shouldn’t it trigger who meleed first? Listen I get on and this happens all the time it’s one of the most annoying things ever.

Link 1
Link 2
Link 3
Link 4
Link 5

It may be annoying but I’ll take trades over “WTF I HIT HIM FIRST!” any day of the week.

> 2533274817492720;2:
> it’s not melee that’s the issue for breakout, it’s the fact that you don’t have a shield. which means one hit melees

But what if it’s a 1 on 1 in breakout but all of the sudden you both hit each other, and it said the enemy team won but no tie?

This issue is not only exclusive to Breakout. I am tired of getting killed by melees and the insanely stupid spartan charge. My greatest issue is the sword block/melee and spartan charge. If someone is at low shields and rushes you with a sword, you can melee but they still won’t die while you do. It is as if the game does not register your melee quite often.

Another nuisance is that vehicle melees don’t work. I have tried so many times to melee someone off a mongoose or warthog and it never registers.

Spartan Charge Nonsense - Look at the absurd range and stun it causes

More Nonsense - Once again absurd range. I also melee’d him upon contact but it did not do anything. I get stunned and die…

Spartan Charge Hit Detection - I jumped out of the way and thrustered, and it still registered.

Attempted Sword Block - Melee the no shields sword guy, and he takes no damage…

wait are you angry that you can melee eachother and both kill eachother? cause thats how its beeen in EVERY single halo title, there is literally nothing wrong with it

> 2533274840624875;9:
> wait are you angry that you can melee eachother and both kill eachother? cause thats how its beeen in EVERY single halo title, there is literally nothing wrong with it

I have not played enough breakout in H5 but in other game modes I rarely get trades.

> 2533274938654117;7:
> > 2533274817492720;2:
> > it’s not melee that’s the issue for breakout, it’s the fact that you don’t have a shield. which means one hit melees
>
>
> But what if it’s a 1 on 1 in breakout but all of the sudden you both hit each other, and it said the enemy team won but no tie?

yeah i feel ya there, it has happened to me many of times

I vastly prefer melee kill trading to one person winning by some indiscernible amount of time that is so small that it comes down to whose connection is better

> 2533274826203061;8:
> This issue is not only exclusive to Breakout. I am tired of getting killed by melees and the insanely stupid spartan charge. My greatest issue is the sword block/melee and spartan charge. If someone is at low shields and rushes you with a sword, you can melee but they still won’t die while you do. It is as if the game does not register your melee quite often.
>
> Another nuisance is that vehicle melees don’t work. I have tried so many times to melee someone off a mongoose or warthog and it never registers.
>
> Spartan Charge Nonsense - Look at the absurd range and stun it causes
>
> More Nonsense - Once again absurd range. I also melee’d him upon contact but it did not do anything. I get stunned and die…
>
> Spartan Charge Hit Detection - I jumped out of the way and thrustered, and it still registered.
>
> Attempted Sword Block - Melee the no shields sword guy, and he takes no damage…

They changed the way the warthog and mongoose melees work. You actually have to look at them now, as opposed to previous titles where you only had to hit the vehicle.

> 2533274851326318;12:
> I vastly prefer melee kill trading to one person winning by some indiscernible amount of time that is so small that it comes down to whose connection is better

This…omg this.

> 2533274832089275;13:
> > 2533274826203061;8:
> >
>
>
> They changed the way the warthog and mongoose melees work. You actually have to look at them now, as opposed to previous titles where you only had to hit the vehicle.

I don’t recall melees doing damage to players when hitting any part of the vehicle. Many times I melee someone on the stupid gungoose only for them to take no damage and then hit me with the stupid explosives that magically aim.

I honestly dislike all the changes the made to physics in H5. Grenade jumping does not really work anymore, all the vehicle have physics that do not make any sense and meleeing is off at times especially with the delay when jumping.