(Notice: It’s all a matter of opinion. Don’t get all mad if you see something you disagree with lol. Feel free to make your own additions if you feel I’ve missed anything. These aren’t listed in any particular order, just what occurs to me. Subject to edits. Spoilers)
We’ll start with the right:
Campaign:
-Sweet looking HUD
-That skybox is purty
-I dig the new covie vehicles
-The abilities are all pretty usable
-The Spartans look pretty sweet
-Solid framerate (mostly)
-Ground-pounding grunts is probably the funniest thing about this game
-Buck
Multiplayer:
-Equal starts
-No more JIP
-Dedicated servers
-The return of Camo/Overshield pickups (as opposed to ordnance drops)
-Thrusters, clamber, and yes even sprint, make the game feel slick.
-Silky smooth 60FPS
-Some new weapons to fool around with
-Lots of variants in weapons for those who play Warzone
-Standard issue weapons for Arena
-Giant Warzone maps
-No more pulse grenades- splinter grenades rule
Wrong
Campaign:
-Loosely-threaded story directed by Michael Bay
-Frame rate/Resolution drops for objects at a distance
-Fireteam Osiris is boring (except Buck sometimes)
-Blue Team is boring
-Not enough Chief
-The told us “Fifteen missions OMG!” we got 12 actual missions and 3 where you just run around and talk to people… man that’s not a MISSION, that’s an errand lol
-They ditched the emotional story Halo 4 told us
-Advertising (and H4) made me believe we would get hella character development… what we got was a handful of Mary Sues
-Hunt the Truth = advertising. It had nothing to do with the game
-I was looking forward to seeing ONI and their shadowy evil-doings and how they affected the campaign… it turns out they’re so shadowy they don’t appear at all D:
-Cliche sci-fi story. We don’t need another Age of Ultron/Terminator
-Graphics. In my opinion, Halo 4 looked better than this game. Especially the grass. It looks like it’s copy-pasted out of the original Borderlands.
Multiplayer
-No split-screen. It’s been said but it can’t be overstated. At first I had no problem with it, but I realize now that I would LOVE to play with my dad, my girlfriend, my brothers, my friends… now they would all have to buy an XB1 and a copy of H5 to play. 343 says they cut it to maintain 60FPS, but let’s be honest they want your friends to buy more copies of H5.
-MicroTs. There used to be a day when unlocking armor meant you had to unlock certain achievements, or perform incredible feats online. Now the guy with that sick helmet just got it cause he dumped $100+ USD on gold packs. That to me really sucks the soul out of Halo.
-Weak customization. We used to have so many more options…
-Ugly armors
-So much quitting! This is a community problem not a game problem, but holy moly.
-Aiming. Recent update makes this a little better, but I still feel like I’m fighting my reticle. It’s weird since I’ll die because I can’t control my reticle, but I’ll sometimes get unfair kills because of magnetism haha.
-Radar is barely relevant.
-Maps are really… boring. We got so many recycled maps and forge maps… seriously. Truth and Regret are basically the same. Same for Empire/Eden. Forge maps are straight up ugly. Reach did a better job for cryin’ out loud! Plus we have a handful of remakes from previous halos, and 4 Warzone maps. It gets really stale really quickly.
-Lack of game modes. No more Oddball, Assault, Juggernaut, Regicide, Infection, Grifball etc. I mean, what do we have? Slayer, Strongholds, Breakout, CTF. $60 USD used to get you a lot more. But people defend this saying “don’t worry it’ll come in next month’s update”. I don’t want to wait month after month for content that was siphoned out to get trickled back in when it should’ve been included since day 1.
-Personally, I dislike Strongholds and would much rather play KOTH. Whenever I play Strongholds it’s either an easy win or a crushing defeat, I rarely have a close game. I think it’s because the first team to start scoring /knows/ where the other team is and can defend correctly (if they’re smart) whereas the other team is gonna have a much harder time because they don’t have that information.
-No in-between from Hardcore Arena and Uber-Casual Warzone.
Congratulations! You’ve made it to the end of the post. Feel free to add stuff ^^