Depends, to be honest, I feel that Halo 4 does deserve GoTY at this point.
An extremely talented and diverse community of people came together, and have been developing the game for 3 years at least now. There are so many factors to why I really think that Halo 4 should or at least will win, and I’m not saying this because of my love of the series.
One obvious reason that I see, is Spartan Ops, someone can correct me if I’m wrong, but ‘weekly episodic content’ much like that of a T.V. series? Has that ever been done before? I don’t think it has, it’s creative and something new to the industry, I can already see other triple A titles following suit if SpOp’s is a hit.
They are also continuing the story of the seventh or sixth best character in videogame history (according to a magazine I saw once, but I think the MC takes the cake over Mario . . . whatever though). The story looks compelling, interesting and fun (the gameplay they have shown has made me more excited for this campaign that any other Halo besides 3’s simply because I thought that would be the ending, and most anticipated that).
They’ve also evolved the multiplayer experience to match something familiar to players, but added features that renew the experience, sure, maybe some of us don’t like all the changes that have happened, but Halo 4 looks like it has a serious chance of revitalizing the popularity it had back in Halo 2 (whether or not the game will be as good as Halo 2).
Of course I haven’t played the game, so I can’t comment on game play, but I have a feeling that Halo 4 will be the game that most deserves the GoTY award. The crew at 343i have especially deserved it, I hope the passion and work they put into the game shines off the disk when I take it out of the box.
Although . . . I have a feeling that even if they don’t win GoTY they will have been satisfied with continuing the series that they love, and the experience of creating a Halo will have been grand enough, more so than some ‘award’. Hell, I don’t think anyone here would hide it anyway, whose dream job would be to work on a Halo game? I don’t think any of us would say no haha.