https://i.imgur.com/nCqU98i.png
Notice it says “UPGRADE TO PREMIUM”?
Saying that the Battle Pass does not expire, implies that the Battle Pass does not expire. Which it doesn’t.
You keep the items that you’ve unlocked during Season 1 of the Battle Pass whether you continue as a Premium user or downgrade to a free user. Even if you were never a Premium user and you only unlocked the free tiers, your free unlocks are still available to you unless you used up the consumable items. Those are 1 time use items.
If you choose not to buy Premium again during Season 2 of the Battle Pass , then you’re downgraded to a free user.
Premium users are given the ability to unlock the items from Season 1 of the Battle Pass even after Season 1 has ended, and they also have that 4th challenge slot available to them while doing so. These are perks that come from being a Premium user.
Free users don’t have these perks. They pretty much only have the ability to play the game and unlock free tiers from the current season of the Battle Pass.
Following so far? You paid for PREMIUM, which gets you the following:
The Premium tiers of Battle Pass which are locked to free users
The 4th challenge slot which is locked to free users
The ability to choose which season of the Battle Pass you’re progressing
Premium expires at the end of each season. Your Battle Pass progress for the past season doesn’t expire.
If you downgrade yourself to a free user (by not purchasing Premium again at the beginning of the new season) then you shouldn’t expect to keep your Premium perks.
You purchased Premium during Season 1 of the Battle Pass. Which gave you the ability to unlock the Premium tiers for Season 1 and a 4th challenge slot to use for the duration of the season. The only thing you didn’t get was the ability to progress a past season due to the fact that there wasn’t one.
You were given what you purchased and your purchase expired.
Your progress is still there. You can go back and finish unlocking the tiers from Season 1 by purchasing Premium again, which will also give you access to the Season 2 Premium tiers and the 4th challenge slot which is locked to you right now as a free user.
You’re tossing everything together and not separating Premium from the Battle Pass or the season. This is leading to all of the confusion and frustration.
Premium and the Battle Pass aren’t the same thing. The Battle Pass is available to everyone. Premium and free users alike. Premium perks aren’t.
The original explanation of how this was all going to work was sloppy at best, but it’s all probably covered in detail in the TOS. That thing that nobody actually reads before agreeing to it.