Can't have more than one guest offline?

Attempted to play a 3 player custom offline last night, when you’re in the lobby it displays whatever gamertag is signed in, and two “press a to join” prompts right under it, being that there are two more controllers connected. Signed in guest 1 just fine, when guest 2 attempts to sign in it only displays one more player under the gamertag that is signed in, guest 1, but it will change every few seconds to guest 2, then back to guest 1. When you start the game only 2 players will be playing. Ended up with 4 separate guest signed in after messing around in the lobby, so that’s 5 profiles with 3 controllers lol. Never got more than 2 people playing in an offline custom. Really really annoying.

Bump need answers

> 2535456411998322;1:
> Attempted to play a 3 player custom offline last night, when you’re in the lobby it displays whatever gamertag is signed in, and two “press a to join” prompts right under it, being that there are two more controllers connected. Signed in guest 1 just fine, when guest 2 attempts to sign in it only displays one more player under the gamertag that is signed in, guest 1, but it will change every few seconds to guest 2, then back to guest 1. When you start the game only 2 players will be playing. Ended up with 4 separate guest signed in after messing around in the lobby, so that’s 5 profiles with 3 controllers lol. Never got more than 2 people playing in an offline custom. Really really annoying.

You can have 4 accounts linked to xbl on the xbone. Create 3 more silver accounts, link them to your current xbl gold account (family account) and you can use them instead