First off I just want to say that I love playing Halo 4. It is my FPS of choice, however due to so much randomness in most game modes even I get frustrated at times.
Yesterday the servers for xbox live went down so basically everyone that did get into a match was set to SR-1. We had a choice of 2 load outs total, and do you know what, it was incredibly fun. Even Infinity Slayer played a lot better IMO.
343 you really need to take a look at what happened yesterday to the servers as a blessing in disguise. The Forums lit up with people saying they liked it a lot, and were going to hop right back on for some more Halo action.
Honestly the game just felt more balanced overall. For example in one match I played a Sword appeared on the map and it was a battle to get it(which I won by the way). The point is that it was incredibly fun to have to fight for that power weapon. To the victor goes the spoils.
I do like the Infinity game type but, it is like a piece of cake. The cake is very tasty, but you don’t want to make it your main meal day after day. We need our meat and potatoes, which in the realm of Halo is the classic settings.
Before someone suggest to me, “Go play Team Throwdown then.” I love playing Team Throwdown, but it is so plagued by quitters it makes it hard to have a good match.
This is what I suggest:
Create a new playlist and call it “Slayer”, and a second one and call it “Social”.
In the social playlist you can place all your Infinity game types, plus some other random just for fun games like Rockets, shotty’s etc…
Take all the other playlist and allow only set load outs as well. I was thinking an AR, and BR load out.
Remove all personal ordnance, and random drops. Initial ones for power weapons are fine IMO if they too are placed on set resupply timers.
Place the other weapons like the DMR, Carbine, LR, etc… on the maps as pick ups only. I would even be fine with Pre patch Bolt shot if it was pick up only weapon.
Remove instant respawn. There really needs to be a penalty for dieing.
subtract points for betrayals, and suicides in the relevant game types.
Place AA’s on the map as pick ups as well.
Well these are my thoughts. I do hope you take some of them to heart and really look at what happened with the servers yesterday as a good indicator to what the Halo fans want.