Anyone else that doesn't like Eden and Regret?

Games Halo 5: Guardians
1

Anyone else that doesn’t like Eden and Regret? I really enjoy playing on Empire, Truth and Pegasus but I really don’t like Eden and Regret.

EDIT:
Regret has useless power weapons (they don’t fit the map) and everyone is camping at the top.

Eden just feels like a bad version of Empire with some a bridge that could be a forge object.

The original variants of the maps Eden and Regret are much better designed which makes me worried about future remix variants of maps. I would suggest 343 to stop making remixes of maps and add more unique and original maps, just leave the remix variants out of the game and focus on creating more unique and different maps instead of remixes.

I hope 343 doesn’t decide to add more Remix variants instead of new maps, that would be a shame and would reduce the variety of maps…

2

I prefer Regret over Eden mainly because of the sniper, but that changes based on which team is controlling which power weapon.

3

I don’t like Regret because its basically everyone camp at the top while the map having the most useless of power weapons. Eden I don’t mind, but I much prefer Empire over it.

4

> 2533274822625446;3:
> I don’t like Regret because its basically everyone camp at the top while the map having the most useless of power weapons. Eden I don’t mind.

I’ve seem more camping on the ledges that are level with the top mid, top mid just looks like a bowl for people to through grenades into.

5

Eden is not that great. Love empire.

6

Regret needs to open up the top middle so people can’t camp there. That’s 90% the problem with that map. Put some big holes in the side structures on top so you can’t take cover as much. People don’t camp top middle in Truth because it’s so open and the map feels so much better for it. Eden needs to be brighter and change the structure of the catwalks. I think the two should be connected by a staircase or a makeshift walkway. That one change would help a lot with map flow. It promotes a lot of camping right now.

7

> 2533275004372869;6:
> Regret needs to open up the top middle so people can’t camp there. That’s 90% the problem with that map. Put some big holes in the side structures on top so you can’t take cover as much. People don’t camp top middle in Truth because it’s so open and the map feels so much better for it. Eden needs to be brighter and change the structure of the catwalks. I think the two should be connected by a staircase or a makeshift walkway. That one change would help a lot with map flow. It promotes a lot of camping right now.

The catwalks feel like they are added with forge and are not designed properly for the mapflow.

I rather have 343 focus on original maps instead of remixes.

8

After playing Empire, I prefer Eden, though I still don’t like either of them.

I actually like Regret.

> Regret needs to open up the top middle so people can’t camp there. That’s 90% the problem with that map

That’s the entire point though. On a map like Truth the middle never gets touched.

9

I don’t like either.

10

i love all the maps personally so far apart from Truth, truth sucks

11

> 2533274819302824;8:
> After playing Empire, I prefer Eden, though I still don’t like either of them.
>
> I actually like Regret.
>
>
>
> > Regret needs to open up the top middle so people can’t camp there. That’s 90% the problem with that map
>
>
> That’s the entire point though. On a map like Truth the middle never gets touched.

And there’s far less camping because of that. People actually move around the map and can’t easily hit you from the other side. If Truth had metal covers instead of destructible energy covers in the middle it’s guaranteed that people would just camp there and pick off other players.

12

I like Eden but Regret can die.

13

I like Eden, but regret better not make it in the final build. That map sucks lol.

343 please remake Guardian from halo 3. PLEASE

14

I like the maps so far uncluding the breakout maps.

the only map i hate is pegasus.

15

> 2533274801839898;13:
> I like Eden, but regret better not make it in the final build. That map sucks lol.
>
> 343 please remake Guardian from halo 3. PLEASE

regret works wonderful with Rocket launcher. and a coordinated team (when it happens). it rock with stronghold. Again when you have players that actually play the objective

16

> 2533274826175302;14:
> I like the maps so far uncluding the breakout maps.
>
> the only map i hate is pegasus.

Come on that map rocks, its alot of fun. (again when you have coordinating teams that work together)

17

The only issue I have at the moment with the maps that there team colour friendly, with Eden for Blues and Regret for Reds but Regret is not to bad.

18

Regret is really the only map I genuinely dislike. The map feels like midship but plays like H3’s epitaph. Extremely congested and cluttered. I understand the idea “a good team should control top mid” but its almost to the point where the set up can’t be broken because of the height advantage looking into narrow walkways of either blue or red spawn.

Each map has its pros and cons. Eden looks a lot like empire and plays similar as well. That and it being extremely congested and cluttered are it’s biggest flaws. Week 2 I barely played due to the “new maps” looking like the last 2 maps with different texture and small additions.

Empire, Truth, and Pegasus are my favorites so far. I would like to see blue/red snipes+no rockets or blue/red snipe+rockets on Pegasus.

19

regret sucks, i prefer breakout maps, idk why

20

dont like eden at all, i love regret