343's Response on Playlists is 100% Inadequate

Let’s get this straight:

  • 343 thought it would be a good idea to release Halo Infinite with essentially just 3 playlists
  • 343 thought it would be a good idea to take beloved classic game modes and only offer them during timed events to sell more microtransactions
  • 343 justifies this by saying they thought there would be a risk of dividing the player base among too many playlists at launch when they have the largest player base
  • 343 now claims it takes weeks to add new playlists like social slayer
  • 343 has only stated that a couple new lists are coming (no news on infection, doubles, multi team, snipers, grifball, permanent Fiesta, action sack, etc…)
  • Nobody at 343 thought it would be worthwhile to get a match composer in the game at launch or even in the launch window, despite this being one of the best received features in MCC

This series of decisions and responses is absolutely unacceptable.

It demonstrates major lapses in judgment about the Halo franchise and how the community likes to play it; there is just no world where the Halo community would receive a game well with only 3 playlists, and anyone who has played Halo at any point since 2004 would have known this immediately.

It demonstrates 343’s most significant ongoing problem: they refuse to admit when they are wrong. It would be really easy for them to say “oops, we goofed, we’ll work on it and do better”. But no, they don’t do that, because it would admit they erred. So what do they do instead? They ask us to understand how hard it is and how much time it takes to add basic playlists liks social slayer. They ask us to appreciate that they just wanted to get a product out the door at all, implying we should just be grateful for it. Honk. Honk. :clown_face:

343, you have a great Halo game here, maybe a game that could be the best game in the series. Please, please, please stop acting as your own worst enemy by making decisions the community tells you are obviously wrong. This isn’t like the sprint debate where the community is genuinely divided. This is basic, obvious stuff where the community is nearly unanimous in opinion that you made some really bad decisions. Get the old expected playlists in and do it ASAP, and then get a match composer in for social shortly after that.

Oh, and while we’re at it, listen to your players on the other three major areas of complaint as well… improve the progression/challenge system, overhaul the customization model to be less scummy and predatory, and turn player collision back on.

11 Likes

It is funny that they’re worried about dividing the player base when they had a game with 5 mp variations, a hand of modes for multiple team sizes as well as weekly modes.

Worst comes to worst they just make the weekly playlist or event mode the least played mode like stronghold is the weekly rotation this week or whatever.

The “dividing the player base” thing is the dumbest excuse possible. It’s astonishing to me that anyone would believe it.

MCC has a tiny playerbase compared to Infinite and the match composer works great with multiple games and playlists.

Splitgate has a tiny playerbase compared to Infinite and the match composer works great.

343 are either lying through their teeth to put out a PR fire, or alternatively are demonstrating an incredible lack of understanding of their game, their community, and how the FPS market works.

4 Likes

Only 2 logical conclusions: They are either lying or incompetent.

3 Likes

Worrying about dividing the player base when now is the time more players will be on than ever makes no sense.

1 Like

Not only is it new, it’s free to play. The notion that there would be an issue of dividing the playerbase at launch with standard playlists that have been in every prior entry is absurd. They’re launching on PC and Xbox (across multiple console generations from what I understand) with crossplay too, so even absent F2P, this seems a safe bet to be the most played Halo game in history. Add F2P on top of that and it’s ensured.

3 Likes

Unless 343 kills it with incompetence, greed, and hubris, which I’m worried is what they are going to do.